City Island, NY homes for sale & real estate

City Island, NY Homes for Sale

Step into your own private sanctuary at 469 Minnieford Avenue, a neatly tucked-away charmer on one of City Island’s most sought-after streets. Lovingly maintained and peacefully set on a double lot, this home sits back from the street, offering exceptional privacy and a sense of calm. Inside, you’re greeted by a warm entry with a gas fireplace and a cozy living room highlighted by exposed beam ceilings that nod to a bygone era. You'll appreciate its character! Beyond the inviting sitting areas, a spacious dining room opens to a true chef’s kitchen—perfect for the family with more than one cook in the house and ideal for everything from intimate meals to large gatheri

City Island, NY Homes for Sale

Discover Seaside Serenity on City Island! Welcome home to this beautiful two-bedroom, cottage-style co-op, ideally situated at the end of a quiet, intimate eight-unit complex in the heart of City Island. This home offers the perfect blend of small-town coastal charm and urban accessibility. Key Features: Cozy & Private Living: A perfect, cozy retreat, this unit features two comfortable bedrooms plus bedroom and bathroom on the first floor, providing flexible living space. Outdoor Oasis: Enjoy your own adorable private porch for morning coffee or evening relaxation, complemented by a small, exclusive side yard—a rare find for co-op living. Prime Location: Centrally located, you a

City Island, NY Homes for Sale

8 Deepwater Way offers the most spectacular on-the-water views at The Boatyard. With absolute privacy, truly breathtaking views, and a highly desirable first-floor layout; this residence stands out as one of the community’s most sought-after and desirable homes. Enjoy expansive open living spaces, and with two of the three ensuite bedrooms conveniently situated on the main level - this home feels like a luxurious private house. Floor-to-ceiling windows & deck-doors frame serene, panoramic water views from every corner, while a private terrace—just off the living room—overlooks the stunning Long Island Sound. - Perfect for dining, relaxing, and practicing your BBQ ski

City Island, NY Homes for Sale

Welcome home to 223 Ditmars Street! This semi-detached beautifully maintained brick home is the perfect mother daughter set up. The first level includes a large bedroom and full bath, and a common space for the washer and dryer. On the second and third levels you’ll enter a three bedroom duplex. Level two you'll find an eat in kitchen with access to rear deck that leads to backyard, a spacious living room and a half bath. The third level features three bedrooms and one full bathroom with a pull down attic stairs . Enjoy water views from the upper levels. One car attached garage and fenced in back yard add to this charming set up. This home is located in the much desirable City Isla