We survey our customers, whether a deal succeeds or fails, and show you their reviews. Learn More
111 HOMES CLOSED IN:

111
Total Deals
$45M
Sales volume
$885K
Highest sales price
About Shelia
Hi! My name is Shelia Reese and I work with buyers in the Madison market. I got my real estate license from the Wisconsin Realtor Association and it's one of the best things I've ever done. I LOVE working with people in this community. In fact, I grew up in Wisconsin and can attest to it being a great place on a great lake. As an advocate, encourager, mentor, and a teacher, I am passionate about helping people find their dream home. Regardless of your budget, your needs, or your timeline, I would love to be your real estate agent. I'm dedicated to giving you a remarkable buying experience. It is my job to earn your business and I’m here, because where you want to go is my destination so, give me a call and tell me more…You can reach me at (608) 530-7556.
Shelia's Listings & Sales
Active Listings (3)
Sold with Shelia (29)
Bought with Shelia (63)
Shelia's Insights
504 Rolling Green Dr Unit G, Fontana-On-Geneva Lake, WI 53125$435,0002 beds1 bath1,000 sq ft504 Rolling Green Dr Unit G, Fontana-On-Geneva Lake, WI 53125Keller Williams Thrive"Beautiful updates and high ceilings."Saw this home 1 Day Ago
1844 Waverly Way, Sun Prairie, WI 53590$679,900 Last sold price4 beds2.5 baths2,722 sq ft1844 Waverly Way, Sun Prairie, WI 53590"This new construction home offers plenty of light throughout. The possibility of adding additional living space in the unfinished basement makes for a great purchase."Saw this home 3 Months Ago
1204 Enterprise Dr, Verona, WI 53593$402,000 Last sold price3 beds3 baths1,770 sq ft1204 Enterprise Dr, Verona, WI 53593"Lots of natural light and very spacious."Saw this home 4 Months Ago
Shelia's Reviews
Most Recent Reviews
4.5
Shelia is very friendly, knowledgeable, and always available to answer questions and address any concerns. As a buyer, I was extremely happy working with her
5.0
She was knowledgeable and answered all my questions
House seller closed Dec '25
1124 Sherman Ave, Fort Atkinson, WI
1124 Sherman Ave, Fort Atkinson, WI
$220K • 2 Bed, 2 Bath, 712 Sq. Ft. • Multiple offers
1.0
If you have an eye for detail, be prepared to supervise this process closely. While Shelia is personable and ultimately got the job done, we calculated a potential $10,000 loss on our $500,000 sale had we not intervened—a critical sum for our retirement. I'd write a longer review to go into detail but it doesn't allow me. We caught six specific errors in legal documents and encountered significant gaps in her knowledge regarding title fee structures. Most concerning was her tendency to create false urgency or incorrect legal "guardrails" to force concessions; she incorrectly claimed commissions couldn't be amended and used factually false liability arguments regarding fully disclosed defects to avoid difficult negotiations. This behavior forced us to verify every fact she provided through independent sources rather than relying on her counsel. Her approach frequently felt biased toward the buyers, prioritizing a speedy close over our financial goals. She dismissed "small" financial differences as insignificant until we explicitly reiterated our budget constraints, and simple logistical questions often required multiple follow-ups. This lack of focus culminated in her mistakenly placing our signatures on the "Buyer" line of a time-sensitive amendment. To her credit, however, once we drew firm boundaries and explained our financial rigidity, her advocacy improved significantly, and she successfully managed buyer expectations in the final days of the transaction. Shelia clearly possesses the interpersonal skills to move transactions forward, and we are grateful to have successfully started our next chapter. However, representing clients with significant assets requires more than just speed; it demands meticulous detail and genuine advocacy. We avoided significant financial loss not because of her diligence, but because we had the business acumen to audit her work and the good fortune of selling in a robust seller’s market. If you choose to work with her, we recommend maintaining a strategy of hyper-vigilance to ensure your specific interests are protected.
4.5
Shelia is great to work with. Never pressures you into a home and always willing to make time for you
5.0
I already have recommended her.
See All Reviews
Why work with a Redfin Agent
Why work with a Redfin Agent
Personal service from a local expert
We live and work in your area and know the market inside out. From pricing to closing, we'll provide the guidance you need at every step.
Better service at a better price
Redfin Agents meet customers on Redfin.com, so they don’t spend time looking for new clients—they focus only on you.
Happier in your new home
Our customer satisfaction rates are consistently higher than the competition, thanks to our technology and local agents.
Meet Shelia's Team
When you work with Redfin, one agent is responsible for your success, but you really get a whole team. Redfin agents work closely with a team of real estate professionals to ensure every sale closes without a hitch.
Manny Tamayo
Transaction Coordinator
Shada Splunge
Listing Coordinator
Popular searches
- Madison Real Estate Agents
- Milwaukee Real Estate Agents
- Lake Geneva Real Estate Agents
- Brookfield Real Estate Agents
- Kenosha Real Estate Agents
- Wauwatosa Real Estate Agents
- Green Bay Real Estate Agents
- Appleton Real Estate Agents
- New Berlin Real Estate Agents
- Mequon Real Estate Agents
- Pleasant Prairie Real Estate Agents
- Menomonee Falls Real Estate Agents
- Franklin Real Estate Agents
- Waukesha Real Estate Agents
- Middleton Real Estate Agents
Popular cities
- Madison Homes for Sale
- Milwaukee Homes for Sale
- Lake Geneva Homes for Sale
- Brookfield Homes for Sale
- Kenosha Homes for Sale
- Wauwatosa Homes for Sale
- Green Bay Homes for Sale
- Appleton Homes for Sale
- New Berlin Homes for Sale
- Mequon Homes for Sale
- Pleasant Prairie Homes for Sale
- Menomonee Falls Homes for Sale
- Franklin Homes for Sale
- Waukesha Homes for Sale
- Middleton Homes for Sale











United States
Canada