We survey our customers, whether a deal succeeds or fails. Learn More
All Reviews
All2024 (18 Homes)
5.0
Tim is a go-getter! I really appreciated Tim helping to find my brother a condo. Thank you!
Condo buyer closed Jul '24
1651 Mentor Ave #1405, Painesville, OH
1651 Mentor Ave #1405, Painesville, OH
$155K • 3 Bed, 1.5 Bath, 1188 Sq. Ft.
5.0
He is an exceptional real estate agent with plenty of experience and even a better personality. Very cheerful, helpful and understanding.
4.5
Tim met us at the drop of a hat for a showing and we never looked back! He’s very professional, courteous of your time and diligent. Thanks Tim!
5.0
Tim McMahon did an awesome job with helping me find my new home. He was extremely patient. He was the buyers agent when I was selling my condo and helped me when an issue came up after closing. I would recommend Timothy Mcmahon to anyone looking to purchase or sell a home.
5.0
Tim is a star agent. He was knowledgeable, helpful and kind in assisting in our home purchase. He answered all our questions promptly and checked out multiple issues for us in a relatively complicated home search. Would highly recommend.
5.0
Tim was available at ALL times for us for both our purchase and the sale of our home. We got the home we wanted and our home sold for more than our asking price. This was such a stressful time for us but Tim helped us make it happen. We are very appreciative for his guidance. Definitely recommend Tim.
5.0
It was truly a pleasure to work with Tim. As a first time owner, Tim helped me minimize my fear by making sure I was informed on all aspects of the buying process. My experience could not have been any better, Tim?made me feel like family. I could tell he was very knowledgeable in his line of business. He provided me with great associates of his who helped make this process smooth sailing. The carpenter he suggested was outstanding, friendly and efficiently.. He worked very well s asa liaison between be me and my loan officer who was also pleasant to work with. I will refer Tim to anyone I know that is looking to purchase a home. Thank you Tim!!!!!
House buyer closed Jul '24
7583 Miami Rd, Mentor On The Lake, OH
7583 Miami Rd, Mentor On The Lake, OH
$189K • 3 Bed, 1.5 Bath, 1080 Sq. Ft.
5.0
Tim was the most hardworking agent I have ever met. Gave us all the information we asked for, and gave us all the information we didn’t even know we needed…lol I would recommend him and have recommended him to anyone I know looking for a house. Couldn’t have dreamed of a better agent to work with.
5.0
Customer did not leave review comments.
5.0
Turn key with the upmost professionalism. Does it like it should be done. Best practice all the way
Condo seller closed May '24
1263 Lost Nation Rd #9, Willoughby, OH
1263 Lost Nation Rd #9, Willoughby, OH
$150K • 2 Bed, 2 Bath, 1092 Sq. Ft.
5.0
Tim McMahon is exceptionally professional and incredibly knowledgeable in the greater Mentor, OH market. He accurately predicted how quickly the house would sell and provided helpful insight to ensure the house looked its best. Tim is proactively pivoting to how the residential real estate industry is evolving and his fees were very competitive. Tim was absolutly excellent to work with and I did not know Tim prior to him listing my home. Tim did what he said he woud do and was readily available. This was particularly important as I now live out of state. If I ever have a real estate transaction in the greater Mentor, OH there's no reason I would look to anyone else.
5.0
Customer chose not to leave public comments.
5.0
Tim was a pleasure to work with in our house buying experience. He is very professional, attentive, easy going, and responsive. He was willing to go the extra mile to help us find the perfect fit. He gave very helpful advice/tips to us as we viewed homes and was not pushy at all in the process. He took our feedback and was able to help us find our lovely new home. I would recommend Tim to anybody that is looking to start the home searching process!
House buyer closed Mar '24
7431 Mountain Park Dr, Concord Township, OH
7431 Mountain Park Dr, Concord Township, OH
$355K • 3 Bed, 2.5 Bath, 1867 Sq. Ft.
4.5
Help me find the perfect home was very comfortable with him could not ask for anything more thank you so much
5.0
By far the very best realtor we’ve ever worked with. Very knowledgeable, extraordinarily quick with responses to inquiries, professional and honest. Altogether a most positive experience.
5.0
Tim has been an excellent realtor. This is the second time working with him and it was flawless. Very knowledgeable in the market and listens to his customer's preferences. Would recommend Tim to anyone without any hesitation!
5.0
Tim was so helpful and efficient from the first call until the end. I couldn’t have imagined a better experience!
House buyer closed Mar '24
27101 Mallard Ave, Euclid, OH
27101 Mallard Ave, Euclid, OH
$145K • 3 Bed, 1.5 Bath, 1410 Sq. Ft. • First-time buyer
5.0
He is professional, accommodating and on top of all new listings that would fit our needs. He was easy and awesome to work with. We would highly recommend him to others. If we ever move again, he would be the only one we would work with.
Condo buyer closed Jan '24
6764 Waterford Ln Unit U-6764, Mentor, OH
6764 Waterford Ln Unit U-6764, Mentor, OH
$325K • 3 Bed, 2 Bath, 2020 Sq. Ft.
2023 (7 Homes)
5.0
Timothy was a very helpful knowledgeable realtor, who bent over backwards to sell our house. He is very patient and more like a friend than a realtor if that makes sense.
5.0
Tim is very responsive, helpful, and honest.
Condo seller closed May '23
16565 Wren Rd Unit F, Chagrin Falls, OH
16565 Wren Rd Unit F, Chagrin Falls, OH
$180K • 2 Bed, 2 Bath, 1232 Sq. Ft.
5.0
Customer chose not to leave public comments.
5.0
Very understanding, wants to get the best price. Tells you the facts on how he will handle the listing and sale. Very quick on getting it on the internet/multiple listings. Best all around experience having him as our realtor.
Condo seller closed Mar '23
11090 Quail Hollow Dr, Concord Township, OH
11090 Quail Hollow Dr, Concord Township, OH
$320K • 3 Bed, 2.5 Bath, 1787 Sq. Ft.
5.0
Got more done in 1 day with him then in 1 year with my previous realtor. Extremely knowledgeable, friendly, and accessible. Fought to make sure I got the best deal possible.
Condo buyer closed Mar '23
9956 Johnnycake Ridge Rd Unit N-3, Concord Township, OH
9956 Johnnycake Ridge Rd Unit N-3, Concord Township, OH
$79K • 2 Bed, 1 Bath, 836 Sq. Ft. • First-time buyer
4.5
Tim is attentive and responds quickly to questions and deal needs
5.0
Customer chose not to leave public comments.
Condo buyer closed Jan '23
160 Fox Hollow Dr #208, Mayfield Heights, OH
160 Fox Hollow Dr #208, Mayfield Heights, OH
$180K • 2 Bed, 2 Bath, 1508 Sq. Ft.
2022 (18 Homes)
5.0
Great agent! Very responsive and knowledgeable.
5.0
Customer did not leave review comments.
Condo seller closed Nov '22
8200 Deepwood Blvd Unit U-10, Mentor, OH
8200 Deepwood Blvd Unit U-10, Mentor, OH
$126K • 2 Bed, 1 Bath, 1076 Sq. Ft.
5.0
Customer chose not to leave public comments.
5.0
Customer did not leave review comments.
4.5
very pleasant and honest. highly recommend. I plan to come to him few years later.
5.0
Tim takes care of everything to make the process move along easily. Answered all questions and is a pleasure to work with. Would use him again.
5.0
I would highly recommend Tim to anyone looking to buy a new home. Tim was on top of everything throughout our entire purchase. He always works to accommodate us and our schedule, but most importantly, answered any question I had and provided his honest opinion on every house we looked at. Which for me, was important, especially with being a first time home buyer. Thank you, Tim!
5.0
Customer did not leave review comments.
5.0
I purchased a rental property with Tim’s help. He is a rock star agent that is efficient and good at what he does. I would work with him again and would recommend others to use him.
House buyer closed Aug '22
Mentor, OH
Mentor, OH
$165K • 3 Bed, 2 Bath, 1468 Sq. Ft.
5.0
Tim is very up front and honest, also very helpful when you want his opinion. Can't say enough good things about him!
5.0
Customer chose not to leave public comments.
5.0
He was great to work with and went above and beyond.
5.0
Tim was great and professional every step of the way, he found me exactly what I was looking for and always answered/responded right away with any questions I had. He has worked with several family members as well. I could not have received better service and appreciate the quality of service I was provided.
House buyer closed May '22
7386 Goldenrod Dr, Mentor-on-the-lake, OH
7386 Goldenrod Dr, Mentor-on-the-lake, OH
$158K • 3 Bed, 1 Bath, 1134 Sq. Ft.
5.0
Customer did not leave review comments.
Condo buyer closed May '22
7560 Monterey Bay Dr #4, Mentor-on-the-lake, OH
7560 Monterey Bay Dr #4, Mentor-on-the-lake, OH
$210K • 2 Bed, 2.5 Bath, 1488 Sq. Ft.
5.0
Tim was very helpful in finding our home.
5.0
Excellent service, recommend him to anyone looking to buy or sell. Started out selling my house, excellent communication, great service! When I finally found my house to purchase he was ready at a moments notice and helped me place an appropriate bid to win the home!
5.0
He is the best realtor I have ever met. I had moved to another state so he set up all repairs and kept me updated on all happenings. Timothy went out of his way to accommodate all involved. He is a very ethical hard worker, and a nice person, too.
5.0
Tim was the most helpful realtor throughout our entire home selling process. He was very communicative about every thing that needed to happen and any concerns/issues that arose. Tim was always positive and reassuring. He was very friendly and very helpful with any questions. Tim always had a solution to any situation we encountered. Tim went out of his way numerous times to help us sell our home and we couldn’t be more appreciative of our experience while working with Tim. Definitely will be contacting him again for any future real estate needs.
2021 (21 Homes)
5.0
Customer chose not to leave public comments.
5.0
Tim was fantastic to work with! Very attentive and helpful!
5.0
Tim was excellent, efficient, timely, technically savvy and we are so pleased we hired him. We highly recommend him to other sellers & buyers.
5.0
Customer chose not to leave public comments.
5.0
Tim made the transaction smooth and painless especially since we were remote buyers. We were very fortunate to have Tim paired with us!
5.0
Timothy was very professional and went above and beyond to make sure that my family and I were in a home that had no issues, no problems, nothing to fix, etc. He did an excellent job and I would absolutely recommend him to anyone looking for a house in and around the area where mine is. 10/10
5.0
Smooth sailing
5.0
Tim was amazing to work with - very tentative & responsive! He was always looking out for us & our interests!
House buyer closed Oct '21
6925 Weatherby Dr, Mentor, OH
6925 Weatherby Dr, Mentor, OH
$320K • 3 Bed, 2.5 Bath, 1954 Sq. Ft. • First-time buyer
5.0
Fantastic agent!! He's so kind, patient, and knowledgeable it's like he's been your best friend forever. You can call him anytime you have any question and he actually answers your call himself or returns it asap. He even goes above and beyond after the sale to make sure tou are happy with you purchase. He was in constant contact with me throughout the entire process.So easy to work with!
5.0
Best Agent! Super responsive and provided great advice. We got our house sold in record time and I would recommend him to anyone buying or selling!
5.0
Friendly, professional, knowledgeable, & efficient! Highly recommend!
5.0
Tim went above and beyond during a long estate process. He was always in contact and helped navigate every aspect of our home sale. Highly recommend his work.
5.0
Customer did not leave review comments.
5.0
Tim was fantastic and always had a solution figured out when calling me about a problem. Would definitely recommend him!
5.0
Absolutely the Best of the Best!! This is the 2nd home we have listed with Tim and bought thru Tim! Professional and caring all wrapped up together to make everything go soo smoothly and on time!!
5.0
Tim was in constant communication, provided a lot of guidance and insight, and we sold quick! Highly recommend.
5.0
Customer did not leave review comments.
5.0
Extremely helpful in all areas.
5.0
Tim went above & beyond as a realtor. He found us reasonably priced home repairmen. He kept us abreast of our sale on a daily basis...pressing a very slow lender to follow through...Tim is the best!!!
House seller closed Mar '21
5438 Meadow Wood Blvd, Lyndhurst, OH
5438 Meadow Wood Blvd, Lyndhurst, OH
$220K • 4 Bed, 2.5 Bath, 2212 Sq. Ft.
4.5
Friendly and very professional. Patient and being so helpful about all my questions. Always return calls or texts.
House buyer closed Mar '21
1299 E 360th St, Eastlake, OH
1299 E 360th St, Eastlake, OH
$105K • 3 Bed, 1 Bath, 960 Sq. Ft. • First-time buyer
5.0
Tim got more money for my house than I thought possible. He was always extremely pleasant and upbeat throughout a rather long and bumpy trail to the listing through closing of my modest home. I don't know what he could have done any better than he did. Thank You, Tim!
2020 (19 Homes)
5.0
Always on top of things, quick to help in finding what I was looking for.
5.0
Tim did an excellent job handling the sell of our condo. Tim maintained constant communication throughout the entire process which made for a smooth transaction.
5.0
Tim went above and beyond! He was thorough and super communicative the entire way. Most importantly he got me more than I expected for my house and then a way better deal than expected on our new house. Would highly recommend.
5.0
I met Tim through my daughter and son-in-law. Tim was their agent when they purchased a home. I liked him right away and knew I wanted him to handle the sale of my home. Tim made the process of selling my home so easy. He is very knowledgeable and could answer my questions right away. If I had a question, he would return my call within 2 minutes even though he was with another client. He went above and beyond to get answers immediately. We had a few problems with the county that he took care of immediately and was able to get services earlier than what the county scheduled. Tim is a very good negotiator, determined to make sure I received the best possible scenario with the sale of my home. I was so at ease with Tim, which is hard for me because usually it takes a long time to process... Show More
House seller closed Dec '20
687 Edgewood Rd, Richmond Heights, OH
687 Edgewood Rd, Richmond Heights, OH
$154K • 3 Bed, 2.5 Bath, 1260 Sq. Ft.
5.0
Tim was great to work with! He was professional, offered great advice, worked very quickly, and had open communication through the entire process. We were under contract after 1 day on the market and are so grateful for his help!
5.0
Friendly,courteous,and smart. Was able to find homes within our budget and our want list.
5.0
Best realtor I've ever worked with. Personable, reliable, and knowledgeable. Tim took ownership as some complexities arose and navigated through finish line. Great communication!
Condo seller closed Nov '20
5510 Wildwood Ct Unit 81-a, Kirtland, OH
5510 Wildwood Ct Unit 81-a, Kirtland, OH
$128K • 3 Bed, 1.5 Bath, 1182 Sq. Ft.
5.0
Timothy, Thank you. Made what could have been a difficult process seem so easy and enjoyable.
5.0
I don't think real estate services are handled any better than what Tim McMahon provides. A recommendation to others is the LEAST I can do to show appreciation for Tim's assistance and guidance. Thanks, Tim!!
5.0
Highly recommend. He answers all my questions. Always available and prompt. Professional A++
5.0
Tim was very receptive to all of requests and answered all of our questions. We had a difficult buyer and he helped navigate the sale.
5.0
It was wonderful working with Tim. He helped us to buy a new home and sell our old home within 6 weeks. It was a quick process for us! Tim gave us helpful advice; patiently answered our questions; and showed that he had our best interest at heart. I can’t say enough about how great our experience was with Tim.
House seller closed Aug '20
16213 Sunny Glenn Ave, Cleveland, OH
16213 Sunny Glenn Ave, Cleveland, OH
$165K • 3 Bed, 2.5 Bath, 2187 Sq. Ft.
4.5
Customer did not leave review comments.
5.0
Customer did not leave review comments.
5.0
Tim takes care of everything, anytime theres a snag he takes care of it. Everyone he works with made everything go smoothly. Couldn’t have had a better experience buying or selling.
5.0
Absolutely wonderful. Up front about every question asked. Would definitely recommend him to everyone. RJ
House seller closed Apr '20
38634 Andrews Ridge Way, Willoughby, OH
38634 Andrews Ridge Way, Willoughby, OH
$395K • 4 Bed, 3.5 Bath, 2654 Sq. Ft.
5.0
Customer chose not to leave public comments.
5.0
He was awesome. He went above and beyond during the process. When looking at homes he let us do our thing and then when we ask his thoughts on it he gave us honest up front answers. He wasn't trying to sell us a house he was helping us find a home.
5.0
Was a huge help. Couldn’t have done it without him! Made it painless and kept me in the loop during the entire process.
2019 (13 Homes)
5.0
Customer did not leave review comments.
House seller closed Dec '19
6065 Campbell Rd, Mentor-on-the-lake, OH
6065 Campbell Rd, Mentor-on-the-lake, OH
$180K • 3 Bed, 1.5 Bath, 1416 Sq. Ft.
5.0
Customer chose not to leave public comments.
5.0
I have bought two house and sold one with Tim. He is a very attentive and patient realtor who makes himself available whenever needed. He knows the business well and is very strategic and always ahead of the game. When it is time to close he knows how to get it done. I wouldn’t work with anyone else.
5.0
Very professional and helpful. Kept us informed each step of the way.
5.0
Customer did not leave review comments.
House buyer closed Sep '19
30018 Vineyard Rd, Willowick, OH
30018 Vineyard Rd, Willowick, OH
$135K • 3 Bed, 2 Bath, 1304 Sq. Ft. • First-time buyer
5.0
He was very patient with us and was not pushy. Very knowledgeable and steered us in the right direction.
Condo buyer closed Sep '19
114 Nantucket Cir, Painesville Township, OH
114 Nantucket Cir, Painesville Township, OH
$165K • 3 Bed, 2 Bath, 1692 Sq. Ft.
5.0
Totally aware of market and what the prices are doing.
House seller closed Apr '19
17495 Merry Oaks Trl, Chagrin Falls, OH
17495 Merry Oaks Trl, Chagrin Falls, OH
$255K • 4 Bed, 2.5 Bath, 2288 Sq. Ft.
5.0
Customer chose not to leave public comments.
5.0
Customer chose not to leave public comments.
House buyer closed Apr '19
7854 Oak St, Mentor, OH
7854 Oak St, Mentor, OH
$165K • 3 Bed, 1.5 Bath, 1692 Sq. Ft. • First-time buyer
5.0
Customer did not leave review comments.
5.0
I would definitely use him again he's already everything precise didn't ask me to do too much to the house because I was selling the house as part of an estate he showed the house for sure late at night that's very helpful to me that tells me that he's doing his job I had it with another realtor thank God for Tim
5.0
Tim awesome and helpful in every step of the way
Condo buyer closed Jun '19
7012 Bristlewood Dr Unit E, Painesville, OH
7012 Bristlewood Dr Unit E, Painesville, OH
$96K • 3 Bed, 2 Bath, 1498 Sq. Ft. • First-time buyer
5.0
Tim is very laid back and easy to work with. He was very helpful and as first time homebuyers explained the entire process to us! He is a great person. Even checked up on us several times after moving in to make sure everything was going well.
2018 (9 Homes)
5.0
Tim was the best Real Estate Agent I have ever worked with. I would challenge anyone to find a more caring and hard working individual.
5.0
We have bought and sold several homes with other agents and Tim was absolutely the best! Tim was always very prompt in responding to our questions and concerns. Tim knows his job well!! Highly recommend Tim!
Condo seller closed Jul '18
11086 Quail Hollow Dr, Painesville, OH
11086 Quail Hollow Dr, Painesville, OH
$225K • 2 Bed, 2 Bath, 1594 Sq. Ft.
5.0
Tim is a wonderful realtor who helped my fiancé and I find our first home!! It is very evident that Tim loves his job. He’s knowledgeable, easy to communicate with, honest, and readily available to meet at homes for tours. Tim even went out of his way to schedule a same day tour of our home because he knew it wouldn’t be on the market long. I have already recommended him to 2 of my friends and he helped them find their first homes, as well!! I highly recommend him for your home buying needs!
House buyer closed Sep '18
6214 Maplewood Rd, Mentor, OH
6214 Maplewood Rd, Mentor, OH
$165K • 4 Bed, 1.5 Bath, 2184 Sq. Ft. • First-time buyer
5.0
Great Agent
House seller closed Aug '18
38495 Crossbrook Ave, Willoughby, OH
38495 Crossbrook Ave, Willoughby, OH
$235K • 3 Bed, 2.5 Bath, 2702 Sq. Ft.
5.0
Amazing communication and follow up skills. All around a great guy who truly works for his clients
5.0
Customer did not leave review comments.
5.0
I overall just had a wonderful experience with him. He was always able to answer my phone calls (at any time of the day) and went above and beyond to get the deal done. I honestly couldn't say enough positive things about this hard working young man.
5.0
Never has anyone been more on top of things then Tim was with my house. I couldn't be happier and have already referred him to many family and friends!
5.0
Hardest working real estate agent i have even come across. I couldn't say enough good things about him as a Realtor or person. I feel lucky to have worked with him!
About us
Find us
Subsidiaries
United States
CanadaCopyright: © 2025 Redfin. All rights reserved.
Updated January 2023: By searching, you agree to the Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.
Do not sell or share my personal information.
REDFIN and all REDFIN variants, TITLE FORWARD, WALK SCORE, and the R logos, are trademarks of Redfin Corporation, registered or pending in the USPTO.
California DRE #01521930
Redfin is licensed to do business in New York as Redfin Real Estate. NY Standard Operating Procedures
New Mexico Real Estate Licenses
TREC: Info About Brokerage Services, Consumer Protection Notice
Rocket Mortgage is an affiliated business of Redfin. All mortgage lending products and information are provided by Rocket Mortgage, LLC | NMLS #3030; www.NMLSConsumerAccess.org. Licensed in 50 states. This site is not authorized by the New York State Department of Financial Services for mortgage solicitation or loan applications activities related to properties located in the State of New York. For additional information on Rocket Mortgage or to receive lending services in the State of New York, please visit RocketMortgage.com.
Rocket Mortgage, LLC, Rocket Homes Real Estate LLC, Rocket Card, LLC, RockLoans Marketplace LLC (doing business as Rocket Loans), and Rocket Money, Inc., are separate operating subsidiaries of Rocket Limited Partnership. Redfin Corporation is an affiliated business of Rocket Limited Partnership. Each company is a separate legal entity operated and managed through its own management and governance structure. Rocket Limited Partnership is an indirect, wholly owned subsidiary of Rocket Companies, Inc. (NYSE: RKT).
If you are using a screen reader, or having trouble reading this website, please call Redfin Customer Support for help at 1-844-759-7732.
REDFIN IS COMMITTED TO AND ABIDES BY THE FAIR HOUSING ACT AND EQUAL OPPORTUNITY ACT. READ REDFIN'S FAIR HOUSING POLICY AND THE NEW YORK STATE FAIR HOUSING NOTICE.