Investors take notice of this fully occupied income producing 4 unit property or occupy one unit and live for free. Spacious 4510 sq. ft of living area, Convenient in-town location, 2-3 bedroom units, 1-2 bedroom unit, 1-1 bedroom unit. Property is located on a corner lot, two driveways, 2 car garage, plenty of off street parking, full attic space that could be finished for additional living space. 1st floor was owners unit and has been updated.
Spacious 4510sqft In-town 4 Unit w/ 2 three bed units, 1 two bed, and 1 one bed unit, oversized Garage. Huge walk up attic, Corner Lot. Great shape w/ off street parking, all appliances stay, rents are below market. Owner is moving out of 1st flr unit
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$7,666 (+6.3%)
$193,800 + $319,300
$513,100
2024
$7,210 (+8.4%)
$193,800 + $313,200
$507,000
2023
$6,652 (+16.7%)
$193,800 + $313,200
$507,000
2022
$5,702 (+6.0%)
$101,300 + $246,200
$347,500
2021
$5,378 (+7.8%)
$84,500 + $210,500
$295,000
2020
$4,988 (+0.3%)
$71,800 + $177,000
$248,800
2019
$4,971 (+1.4%)
$71,800 + $177,000
$248,800
2018
$4,901 (+11.1%)
$71,800 + $177,000
$248,800
2017
$4,411 (+1.1%)
$71,800 + $148,000
$219,800
2016
$4,365 (+2.0%)
$71,800 + $148,000
$219,800
2015
$4,280 (−9.0%)
$71,800 + $148,000
$219,800
2013
$4,703
$88,300 + $180,000
$268,300
Tax history for 56 Prospect St
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$7,666 (+6.3%)
$193,800 + $319,300
$513,100
2024
$7,210 (+8.4%)
$193,800 + $313,200
$507,000
2023
$6,652 (+16.7%)
$193,800 + $313,200
$507,000
2022
$5,702 (+6.0%)
$101,300 + $246,200
$347,500
2021
$5,378 (+7.8%)
$84,500 + $210,500
$295,000
2020
$4,988 (+0.3%)
$71,800 + $177,000
$248,800
2019
$4,971 (+1.4%)
$71,800 + $177,000
$248,800
2018
$4,901 (+11.1%)
$71,800 + $177,000
$248,800
2017
$4,411 (+1.1%)
$71,800 + $148,000
$219,800
2016
$4,365 (+2.0%)
$71,800 + $148,000
$219,800
2015
$4,280 (−9.0%)
$71,800 + $148,000
$219,800
2013
$4,703
$88,300 + $180,000
$268,300
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.
Public record
Public record
Zoning
Beds
9
Baths
4
Stories
2
Lot width
—
Lot depth
—
Lot size
6,098 Sq. Ft.
Year renovated
—
Sq. Ft.
4,510
Year built
1870
Style
Multi-Family (5+ Unit)
County
York County
APN
160375
Parking Spaces
—
Basement
—
Accessible
—
HOA Dues
—
Garage
—
Features
—
Last updated by owner on Jul 30, 2026.
R2
Residential Zone
These areas are higher-density multifamily neighborhoods which allow for a mixture of residential uses. These areas are served by water and sewer.