This exceptional Princeton estate is so much more than just a place to call home. It’s an opportunity to cultivate a lifestyle that encourages hosting, recreation, wellness and creative pursuits, all in one spectacular setting totaling over 26 acres. The classic Georgian brick house was built for a legendary sports franchise owner, who frequently entertained on a grand scale. Currently, an avid art collector uses the expertly renovated spaces to showcase contemporary works surrounded by traditional architectural features, like layered moldings, French doors and wide-plank antique floors. Fireplaces grace several rooms, including the formal areas and a paneled library. A radiant-heated sunroom and broad bluestone terraces overlook a recently added saltwater pool, while a gazebo, a pergola and whimsically striped awnings offer plenty of shelter from the summer sun. The brick breakfast room’s built-in BBQ is a rustic alternative to the brilliant white kitchen with marble countertops, custom glass cabinetry and paneled appliances - truly, the height of culinary elegance, complete with a full-size wine fridge and a double Thermador range. A roomy first floor guest suite, currently serving as an office/family room, shows its flexibility, as does a multi-room suite atop the gracefully curving main staircase. There are six bedrooms in total and every spotless bathroom is beautifully tiled, but none compare to the primary suite dressed in new designer wallpaper and lighting. The custom-detailed dressing room, vanity station and mosaic marble bath are stunning spots to prepare for the day or an evening out. In addition to the recently finished basement, a speakeasy-style wing with separate entrance hosts movie nights, pool tournaments, Super Bowl parties and more. But for momentous celebrations, head to the newly built 4-bay party barn with finished upper level! Clad in character-rich mushroom wood, this clean-as-can-be structure is also ideal for the car collector or artist of any kind. The manicured grounds include a tennis court and pollinator-friendly gardens, while nature trails spread far and wide through the woods. This gated compound, which is farm-assessed, straddles the Lawrence/Princeton Township line, putting it within an easy drive of so many top-notch schools, both public and private. Plus, Jasna Polana’s championship golf course is right next door! Owner is NJ Licensed Real Estate Agent.
Single-familyProperty Type
1968Year Built
26.81 acresLot Size
$620Price/Sq.Ft.
Listed by Sylmarie Trowbridge• Callaway Henderson Sotheby's Int'l-Princeton
•609-921-1050 (broker)
•info@callawayhenderson.com (broker)
Bought with Sue Havens• Callaway Henderson Sotheby's Int'l-Princeton
Est. $6,959 per month, based on comparable rentals
Sale and tax history for 4535 Province Line Rd
Sale History
Tax History
Date
Event
Price
BRIGHT MLS #NJME2075622
Jul 2, 2026
Sold
$5,300,000
$620/sq ft
Jun 19, 2026
Pending
—
May 1, 2026
Contingent
—
Apr 17, 2026
Listed
$5,895,000
$690/sq ft
BRIGHT MLS #NJME2064522
Mar 2, 2026
Listing Removed
—
Oct 6, 2025
Relisted
—
Oct 3, 2025
Listing Removed
—
Sep 12, 2025
Listed
$6,250,000
$731/sq ft
Sep 10, 2025
Coming Soon
*
TREND #5946378
Aug 30, 2012
Sold
$1,664,938
$195/sq ft
Aug 4, 2012
Pending
—
Apr 13, 2012
Price Changed
$1,950,000
$228/sq ft
Sep 13, 2011
Listed
$2,495,000
$292/sq ft
BRIGHT MLS #1004513264
Aug 30, 2012
Sold
$1,664,938
$195/sq ft
Jul 13, 2012
Listing Removed
—
Sep 13, 2011
Listed
$1,950,000
$228/sq ft
+11
Available for the first time, this brick colonial is located on over 26 private acres. Gleaming wide-board floors and beautiful mouldings along with antique mantles and 10 foot ceilings are just a few of the special features. A gracious entrance hall flows seamlessly to the formal rooms which include a step down living room with French doors to the expansive terrace, intimate wood paneled library, sunroom and pretty dining room. A breakfast room adjoins the large eat-in kitchen and butler's pantry. Nearby is a family room and full bath. The dramatic stair hall and curved staircase leads to the second floor which features six bedrooms and four baths. Beyond the 3-car garage, a tennis court is perfectly placed. Woodland paths meander through much of this property, 19 acres of which have a conservation easement. This very private setting just minutes from Palmer Square provides the perfect backdrop to this stunning home. Taxes are being appealed.