For sale

$399,421

Est. $2,505/mo —

•

—

sq ft

5 W Shaytown Rd, Sandyston, NJ 07827-5109

About this home

Live Where You Play! Welcome to this charming 2-bedroom, 1-bath ranch set on over an acre of beautifully flat, private property. Full of character & thoughtfully maintained, home offers comfortable 1-level living w/ plenty of outdoor space to enjoy. Enter into inviting living/dining area, filled w/ character & warmth, featuring distinctive brick pillars, beamed ceiling, & brick-surround woodstove that creates cozy focal point. Nicely appointed kitchen offers butcher-block countertops, tile backsplash & SS appliances. Both BR feat easy-care laminate flooring. Spacious main BR boasts 2 closets & charming beamed ceiling. Tiled laundry/mud room provides convenient everyday functionality & feat door leading to covered patio & wonderful private backyard perfect spot for relaxing, entertaining or enjoy peaceful setting. Property also incl detached garage w/ opener & greenhouse, offering plenty of room for storage, hobbies, gardening & outdoor projects. Recent & well-maintained mechanicals add peace of mind, incl roof, oil tank & furnace approximately 3 years young & well pump approx 10 years. Conveniently located near Milford & Port Jervis w/ easy access to Rte 206 for commuters. Outdoor enthusiasts will love proximity to Milford Beach, Delaware River, Stokes State Forest, Appalachian Trail, Historic Walpack & Buttermilk Falls. Wonderful opportunity to enjoy charm of country living while being close to everything you need. Come home, relax, explore & truly live where you play!

Single-familyProperty Type

1940Year Built

1.16 acresLot Size

1 garage spacesParking

Listed by DEBRA KISTLE • KISTLE REALTY, LLC.

Contact: 973-250-3299

Listing updated: Aug 17, 2026 at 12:33am

Redfin checked: 2 minutes ago

•Source:GSMLS #4046097

Payment calculator

$2,505 per month

Principal and interest$2,073

Property taxes

$369

HOA dues

Home insurance

$63

Utilities

Add

5 minutes to get started. No credit impact.

Mortgage resources

See this home in person

We'll connect you with a local agent to show you this home, answer your questions, and assist you on your buying journey.

Next available tour time: Tomorrow

Open houses

No upcoming open houses.

Nearby open houses (8)

OPEN FRI, 3PM TO 7PM3D WALKTHROUGH
$489,000
4 beds3.5 baths3,132 sq ft
203 W Harford St, Milford, PA 18337
OPEN SAT, 12PM TO 3PM
$419,999
3 beds2 baths— sq ft
81 Possaghi Rd, Newton, NJ 07860-6439
OPEN SAT, 1PM TO 3PM
$430,000
4 beds1.5 baths— sq ft
16 Essex Rd, Sussex, NJ 07461-1110
OPEN SAT, 1PM TO 3PM
$249,900
3 beds1.5 baths1,865 sq ft
113 Bailey Dr, Bushkill, PA 18324
(570) 424-8850
OPEN SUN, 12PM TO 3PM
$395,000
3 beds2.5 baths1,768 sq ft
9 Ferndale Ln, Hamburg, NJ 07419-9730
OPEN SUN, 12PM TO 3PM
$624,900
3 beds3 baths3,314 sq ft
11 Summit Dr, Branchville, NJ 07826-4405
OPEN SUN, 1PM TO 4PM3D WALKTHROUGH
$499,999
3 beds2.5 baths— sq ft
7 Galloping Hill Rd, Montague, NJ 07827-3204
OPEN SUN, 1PM TO 3PM
$865,000
4 beds2.5 baths2,900 sq ft
2 Bonning Rd, Newton, NJ 07860-4946

Around this home

Schools

K - 12
Preschool & daycare

Sandyston-Walpack Cons. Elementary School

Public PreK-6 • Assigned • 3.6mi

7/10

Kittatinny Regional High School

Public 7-12 • Assigned • 11.0mi

5/10

Provided by GreatSchools

Lifestyle

Provided by Walk Score and Local Logic

Offer insights

5 W Shaytown Rd · $399,421

Strong offer

$422K and above

75% chance or better to win

Why $422K+ is a strong offer

DAYS ON MARKET

The average home goes pending in 24 days.

SALE-TO-LIST

Most homes are selling 3% above list price.

About offer insights

Property details

Interior
Exterior
Finance

Kitchen

Bathroom

Bedroom

Living

Dining

Interior features
Carbon monoxide detector
Smoke detector
Wood stove freestanding in the living room (fireplace)

Bedrooms
Primary bedroom on the first floor
Second bedroom on the first floor
Bedroom sizes: ~14x13 and ~12x9

Bathrooms
One full bathroom

Kitchen
Country-style eat-in kitchen
Appliances: Dishwasher, Microwave, Electric range/oven, Refrigerator

Laundry & utility
First-floor laundry room
Basement utility room

Flooring
Laminate
Tile

Heating & cooling
Forced hot air heating
Ceiling fan for cooling

Sale and tax history for 5 W Shaytown Rd

Sale History
Tax History

Year

Property tax

Land + Additions

Assessment*

2025

$4,430 (+5.6%)

$68,900 + $63,800

$132,700

2024

$4,193 (+3.1%)

$68,900 + $63,800

$132,700

2023

$4,066 (+4.6%)

$68,900 + $63,800

$132,700

2022

$3,885 (+3.2%)

$68,900 + $63,800

$132,700

2021

$3,765 (+4.3%)

$68,900 + $63,800

$132,700

2020

$3,608 (+4.5%)

$68,900 + $63,800

$132,700

2019

$3,452 (+0.6%)

$68,900 + $63,800

$132,700

2018

$3,430 (+1.7%)

$68,900 + $63,800

$132,700

2017

$3,372 (+7.5%)

$68,900 + $63,800

$132,700

2016

$3,137 (−15.7%)

$68,900 + $63,800

$132,700

2014

$3,720 (−4.2%)

$68,900 + $63,800

$132,700

2013

$3,882 (+5.7%)

$113,200 + $80,200

$193,400

2012

$3,672 (+5.2%)

$113,200 + $80,200

$193,400

2011

$3,490 (−3.0%)

$113,200 + $80,200

$193,400

2010

$3,599 (+1.9%)

$113,200 + $80,200

$193,400

2009

$3,531

$113,200 + $80,200

$193,400

Public record

Public record
Zoning

Beds

—

Baths

—

Stories

Lot width

—

Lot depth

—

Lot size

1.16 Acres

Year renovated

—

Finished Sq. Ft.

926

Unfinished Sq. Ft.

—

Total Sq. Ft.

926

Year built

1940

Style

Single Family Residential

County

Sussex County

APN

1700801 00002

Parking Spaces

—

Basement

—

Accessible

—

HOA Dues

—

Garage

—

Features

—

Last updated by owner on Aug 26, 2026.

Climate risks

1/10 Flood Factor

Minimal risk of a flood reaching the building in the next 30 years

1/10 Fire Factor

Unlikely to be in a wildfire in next 30 years

4/10 Heat Factor

7 days above 95° expected this year, 15 days in 30 years

4/10 Wind Factor

8% chance of strong winds in next 30 years

2/10 Air Factor

1 unhealthy days expected this year, 2 days in 30 years

Provided by First Street

Historical weather

Sandyston, NJ • 07827-5109

Average low and high temperatures (°F)

Jan

Feb

Mar

Apr

May

Jun

Jul

Aug

Sep

Oct

Nov

Dec

Sun exposure

79/ 100

Good sunlight

Sunscore

There appears to be minimal shading by surrounding buildings, terrain, and vegetation.

8.9 hrs

5.5 hrs

JuneDecember

Provided by Shadowmap

Redfin Estimate for 5 W Shaytown Rd

$400,668

$1,247 over list price of $399K

Nearby comparable homes

The Redfin Estimate uses 6 recent nearby sales, priced between $319K to $425K.

SOLD DEC 15, 2025
176 New Rd, Montague, NJ 07827-3418
$375,000 Last sold price
3 beds2 baths— sq ft
176 New Rd, Montague, NJ 07827-3418
smaller lot
41 years newer
no basement
SOLD JUN 29, 2026
215 New Rd, Montague, NJ 07827-3506
$415,000 Last sold price
3 beds2 baths— sq ft
215 New Rd, Montague, NJ 07827-3506
smaller lot
47 years newer
no basement
SOLD JUN 9, 2026
317 Wagon Wheel Rd, Montague, NJ 07827
$319,000 Last sold price
2 beds1 bath— sq ft
317 Wagon Wheel Rd, Montague, NJ 07827
smaller lot
35 years newer
no basement
SOLD JUL 16, 2026
11 Fox Run, Montague, NJ 07827-3424
$410,000 Last sold price
3 beds2 baths— sq ft
11 Fox Run, Montague, NJ 07827-3424
smaller lot
55 years newer
no basement
SOLD JUL 31, 2026
$425,000 Last sold price
3 beds1 bath1,152 sq ft
191 Foster Hill Rd, Milford, PA 18337
larger lot
27 years newer
SOLD APR 24, 2026
$365,000 Last sold price
3 beds1 bath— sq ft
5 Piney Rd, Montague, NJ 07827-3004
48 years newer
no basement

Rental earnings

Est. $1,744 per month, based on comparable rentals

Tour for free, no strings attached

Instant answers, or connect with a local agent

Start an offer