Put down your roots at this country haven with over 9 acres to plant, cultivate, and tend or just wander and wonder. Here you will find forest, fields, fenced areas and multiple outbuildings with electricity including a spacious workshop with pellet stove, chicken coop complex and a huge garage! The established organic gardens with raspberries, asparagus and blueberry bushes are ready to go. Inside the updated and expanded cape style home, windows flank the multiple living spaces bringing in an abundance of natural light. Handcrafted cabinetry, gleaming wood floors and a stunning Waterford Stanley cook stove are just a few of this home's impressive features. There are two bedrooms and a full bath on the main floor as well as a separate private upstairs space with a bedroom, full bath and additional space for work, hobbies, or quiet time. Just minutes away is Cayuta Lake where you can fish and launch your motor boat or kayak. Drive or bike around the lake to enjoy the extensive trails in the Connecticut Hill Wildlife Management Area. High speed fiber optic internet fit for work and play. Less than 15 miles to Ithaca, Trumansburg and Watkins Glen. Delayed offer review - May 7th.
Single-familyProperty Type
1931Year Built
9.2 acresLot Size
$248Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
2 car garageParking
Listing by Gillian Ryan• Howard Hanna S Tier Inc
Contact: 607-592-9755
Bought with Claudia Lagalla• Howard Hanna S Tier Inc
Claim this home to receive a free report every month with insights on the changing estimate.
Earn from this home
Refinance
$0
Est. cash available
Get cash now or lower your monthly rate
Market trends in 14805, NY
Last updated August 2026
Sale-to-List Price
96.4%
+0.5% MoM
Median sale price
$386K
$74K MoM
Avg. days on market
79d
40 days MoM
Recently sold homes
3
1 MoM
Provided by Redfin
Sale history for 5751 Cayutaville Rd
Date
Event
Price
IBRMLS #R1532907
Jul 12, 2024
Sold
$382,000
$191/sq ft
Jun 14, 2024
Pending
—
May 10, 2024
Contingent
—
Apr 30, 2024
Listed
$350,000
$175/sq ft
UNYREIS #EC274185
Apr 30, 2024
Listed
$350,000
$175/sq ft
IBRMLS #405340
Dec 10, 2021
Sold
$305,000
$152/sq ft
Sep 8, 2021
Listed
$295,000
$147/sq ft
IBRMLS #IB405340
Dec 10, 2021
Sold
$305,000
$152/sq ft
Sep 8, 2021
Listed
$295,000
$147/sq ft
This homesteaders dream will leave you longing for easier times. Built as a JR Bennett Kit home in the 1930's, the property has been expanded on and remodeled over the years. Just yards from the Northern Cayuta Lake Fishing Access Site. for all you water lovers. Custom made cabinets, a Waterford Stanley wood cook stove, a spacious dining area with a built in hutch. Hydronic radiant floor heat under tiled floors, bright open living room, two bedrooms and full bath on main floor. Master suite on the second floor. Inside access to basement. For the past 38 years the owners have added an oversized garage, raised cinderblock beds, asparagus, berries, blueberry bushes. Let's not forget the 16X20 woodworking shop with a pellet stove and ample electricity. A chicken house large enough for all your ladies with electricity and a large fenced yard. Several out buildings all on 9+ acres of pesticide and fertilizer free land. Fiber optic internet through Empire Access. Come, Breath!
UNYREIS #EC264547
Sep 8, 2021
Listed
$295,000
$147/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2026
$5,864
$59,600 + $268,100
$327,700
2025
$5,864 (+0.6%)
$59,600 + $268,100
$327,700
2024
$5,826 (+75.9%)
$59,600 + $268,100
$327,700
2023
$3,313 (−0.3%)
$36,000 + $81,000
$117,000
2022
$3,321 (+7.1%)
$36,000 + $81,000
$117,000
2021
$3,101 (+14.3%)
$36,000 + $81,000
$117,000
2020
$2,713 (+1.3%)
$36,000 + $81,000
$117,000
2019
$2,679 (−2.8%)
$36,000 + $81,000
$117,000
2018
$2,757 (+1.2%)
$36,000 + $81,000
$117,000
2017
$2,725 (−5.9%)
$36,000 + $81,000
$117,000
2016
$2,896 (−1.4%)
$36,000 + $81,000
$117,000
2015
$2,937 (−0.9%)
$30,000 + $84,000
$114,000
2014
$2,965
$30,000 + $84,000
$114,000
Tax history for 5751 Cayutaville Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2026
$5,864
$59,600 + $268,100
$327,700
2025
$5,864 (+0.6%)
$59,600 + $268,100
$327,700
2024
$5,826 (+75.9%)
$59,600 + $268,100
$327,700
2023
$3,313 (−0.3%)
$36,000 + $81,000
$117,000
2022
$3,321 (+7.1%)
$36,000 + $81,000
$117,000
2021
$3,101 (+14.3%)
$36,000 + $81,000
$117,000
2020
$2,713 (+1.3%)
$36,000 + $81,000
$117,000
2019
$2,679 (−2.8%)
$36,000 + $81,000
$117,000
2018
$2,757 (+1.2%)
$36,000 + $81,000
$117,000
2017
$2,725 (−5.9%)
$36,000 + $81,000
$117,000
2016
$2,896 (−1.4%)
$36,000 + $81,000
$117,000
2015
$2,937 (−0.9%)
$30,000 + $84,000
$114,000
2014
$2,965
$30,000 + $84,000
$114,000
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.
Public record
Beds
3
Baths
2
Stories
1.5
Lot width
—
Lot depth
—
Lot size
9.2 Acres
Year renovated
2000
Sq. Ft.
2,001
Year built
1931
Style
Vacant Land
County
Schuyler County
APN
442089A06800000010130020000
Parking Spaces
—
Basement
—
Accessible
—
HOA Dues
—
Garage
—
Features
—
Last updated by owner on Aug 10, 2026.
Property details
Parking
Parking/Garage Information
Has Garage
# of Garage Spaces: 2
Parking Features: Gravel, Detached, Garage, Workshop in Garage, Garage Door Opener, Driveway