East Seneca Lake with 2 Cottages; Main Cottage has 2 bedrooms that overlooks the Lake, Lower Cottage (375 sq') Dock. Main Cottage has Several Large Decks to Sit and Relax w views of Lake or Mature Trees. Lake level 1 Bedroom Cottage can be a guest retreat or rental income. A boat house located under the Lower Cottage has storage for all your Lake Toys. Deck on the Lower Cottage is simply perfect for relaxing or entertaining. Dock has Electric Boat Lift, Large Sitting Area, and a Slide! Conveniently located on the Seneca Wine Trail. Just minutes from Watkins Glen. This two for one won't last long.
Single-familyProperty Type
1958Year Built
6,970 sq ftLot Size
$824Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
Listing by Vivian Schamel• Keller Williams Realty Southern Tier & Finger Lakes
•607-795-2900 (broker)
•vickischamel@kw.com (broker)
Bought with Vivian Schamel• Keller Williams Realty Southern Tier & Finger Lakes
Claim this home to receive a free report every month with insights on the changing estimate.
Earn from this home
Refinance
$0
Est. cash available
Get cash now or lower your monthly rate
Rent
$1,642/mo
Redfin rental estimate
List your home for rent
Market trends in 14841, NY
Last updated August 2026
Sale-to-List Price
96.3%
0.0% MoM
Median sale price
$600K
$260 MoM
Avg. days on market
56d
0 days MoM
Recently sold homes
2
0 MoM
Provided by Redfin
Sale history for 5165 Club Seneca Rd
Date
Event
Price
UNYREIS #R1075311
Sep 21, 2018
Sold
$230,000
$383/sq ft
Sep 12, 2017
Listed
$279,900
$467/sq ft
IBRMLS #IB311368
Sep 12, 2018
Sold
$230,000
$383/sq ft
Sep 12, 2017
Listed
$279,900
$467/sq ft
East Seneca Lake with 2 Cottages; Main Cottage has 2 bedrooms that overlooks the Lake, Lower Cottage (375 sq') Dock. Main Cottage has Several Large Decks to Sit and Relax w views of Lake or Mature Trees. Lake level 1 Bedroom Cottage can be a guest retreat or rental income. A boat house located under the Lower Cottage has storage for all your Lake Toys. Deck on the Lower Cottage is simply perfect for relaxing or entertaining. Dock has Electric Boat Lift, Large Sitting Area, and a Slide! Conveniently located on the Seneca Wine Trail. Just minutes from Watkins Glen. This two for one won't last long.
UNYREIS #EC249036
Sep 21, 2018
Sold
$230,000
$383/sq ft
Sep 8, 2017
Listed
$279,900
$467/sq ft
East Seneca Lake with 2 Cottages; Main Cottage has 2 bedrooms that overlooks the Lake, Lower Cottage (375 sq') Dock. Main Cottage has Several Large Decks to Sit and Relax w views of Lake or Mature Trees. Lake level 1 Bedroom Cottage can be a guest retreat or rental income. A boat house located under the Lower Cottage has storage for all your Lake Toys. Deck on the Lower Cottage is simply perfect for relaxing or entertaining. Dock has Electric Boat Lift, Large Sitting Area, and a Slide! Conveniently located on the Seneca Wine Trail. Just minutes from Watkins Glen. This two for one won't last long.
UNYREIS #EC245365
Jan 6, 2017
Listing Removed
—
Aug 26, 2016
Listed
$292,000
$487/sq ft
IBRMLS #IB307397
Aug 27, 2016
Listed
$292,000
$487/sq ft
UNYREIS #EC218376
Jul 1, 2009
Sold
$240,000
$400/sq ft
Apr 19, 2009
Listed
$259,000
$432/sq ft
UNYREIS #EC217217
Mar 15, 2009
Listing Removed
—
Dec 17, 2008
Listed
$275,000
$458/sq ft
UNYREIS #EC204911
Mar 3, 2006
Sold
$215,000
$358/sq ft
Jul 27, 2005
Listed
$225,000
$375/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2026
$5,801
$127,000 + $151,000
$278,000
2025
$5,801 (+3.0%)
$127,000 + $151,000
$278,000
2024
$5,631 (+1.4%)
$127,000 + $151,000
$278,000
2023
$5,554 (+1.6%)
$127,000 + $151,000
$278,000
2022
$5,469 (−7.4%)
$127,000 + $151,000
$278,000
2021
$5,903 (−0.2%)
$120,000 + $136,000
$256,000
2020
$5,914 (+0.3%)
$120,000 + $136,000
$256,000
2019
$5,895 (+12.1%)
$120,000 + $136,000
$256,000
2018
$5,257 (−0.5%)
$120,000 + $136,000
$256,000
2017
$5,285 (−11.8%)
$100,000 + $136,000
$236,000
2016
$5,989 (+21.9%)
$100,000 + $136,000
$236,000
2015
$4,914
$75,000 + $135,000
$210,000
2014
$4,918
$75,000 + $135,000
$210,000
Tax history for 5165 Club Seneca Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2026
$5,801
$127,000 + $151,000
$278,000
2025
$5,801 (+3.0%)
$127,000 + $151,000
$278,000
2024
$5,631 (+1.4%)
$127,000 + $151,000
$278,000
2023
$5,554 (+1.6%)
$127,000 + $151,000
$278,000
2022
$5,469 (−7.4%)
$127,000 + $151,000
$278,000
2021
$5,903 (−0.2%)
$120,000 + $136,000
$256,000
2020
$5,914 (+0.3%)
$120,000 + $136,000
$256,000
2019
$5,895 (+12.1%)
$120,000 + $136,000
$256,000
2018
$5,257 (−0.5%)
$120,000 + $136,000
$256,000
2017
$5,285 (−11.8%)
$100,000 + $136,000
$236,000
2016
$5,989 (+21.9%)
$100,000 + $136,000
$236,000
2015
$4,914
$75,000 + $135,000
$210,000
2014
$4,918
$75,000 + $135,000
$210,000
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.