Nestled in the heart of the Catskill Mountains with direct frontage on the one-and-only Catskill Creek, this charming two bedroom, one bathroom cottage on almost two acres strays from convention. Inside, you’ll be greeted by the original stone hearth fireplace with modern cement wash, genuine pine tongue and groove walls, and newly refinished hardwood floors using nontoxic stains. Original posts and beams are exposed and adorned with modern brass fixtures. Surrounded by 5 state forests, there’s no shortage of natural surroundings not to mention a variety of local enticements including hikes, preserves, Middleburgh Coffee Co. , Broome Animal Sanctuary, Green Wolf Brewing, and more. Upgrades include a full cosmetic refresh: handcrafted shou sugi ban wood siding, custom kitchen cabinetry, SMEG fridge, Forno Stove, Forte dishwasher, and Samsung washer and dryer, refinished farmhouse sink, cle handmade tiles, refinished cast iron tub, unlaquered brass faucets, and custom fixtures. Across the tree-lined drive, there is an additional . 9 acres currently being kept as a pollinator field, and spacious enough for a second structure such as a studio or workshop.
Single-familyProperty Type
1932Year Built
1.9 acresLot Size
$449Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
2 spacesParking
Listing by Arlena Armstrong-Petock• Country House Realty
Nestled in the heart of the Catskill Mountains with direct frontage on the one-and-only Catskill Creek, this charming two bedroom, one bathroom cottage on almost two acres strays from convention. Historic details are paired with environmentally mindful and modern refinements to create a unique celebration of nature, closeness, and the present. Inside, you’ll be greeted by the original stone hearth fireplace with modern cement wash, genuine pine tongue and groove walls, and newly refinished hardwood floors using nontoxic stains. The cottage, which feels like a sibling to the famed J. B. Blunk house, is a Catskills fairy tale. Original posts and beams are exposed and adorned with modern brass fixtures. Through the entry room, you’ll find a custom kitchen, renovated bathroom, and sunny, open living and dining area. At the top of the stairway, the large, new skylight looks out to the canopy. You can see the natural hemp insulation in the attic closets of both bedrooms upstairs, and hear the Catskill Creek outside the original windows. Surrounded by 5 state forests, there’s no shortage of natural surroundings not to mention a variety of local enticements including hikes, preserves, Middleburgh Coffee Co. , Broome Animal Sanctuary, Green Wolf Brewing, and more. Upgrades include a full cosmetic refresh: newly installed, handcrafted shou sugi ban wood siding and pine sheathing, new custom kitchen cabinetry made right here in NY, all new top-tier appliances such as a SMEG fridge, Forno Stove, Forte dishwasher, and Samsung washer and dryer, a vintage, newly refinished farmhouse sink, Hudson Reed electric cast-iron radiators, cle handmade tiles, a vintage, newly refinished cast iron tub from the Historic Albany Foundation, unlaquered brass faucets meant to patina, and custom fixtures. Not to be missed: details such as a brand new eastern white cedar shingle roof with rainscreen and new skylight, all new hemp insulation throughout with red-list-free membrane, plant based paint, freshly parged and refinished basement, new 1000g concrete septic tank and leach field designed by Lamont Engineers, conversion to all electric utilities, buried electric line and new panel, new wiring, all new plumbing, new on-demand electric water heater, and more. The home lives and breathes with the landscape, mirroring the surrounding mountain range, at one with nature. Across the tree-lined drive, there is an additional . 9 acres currently being kept as a pollinator field, and spacious enough for a second structure such as a studio or workshop. Middleburgh is less than 2.5 hours from Manhattan, 15 minutes from Rensselaerville, less than 30 minutes from Windham Mountain ski resort, 35 minutes from Stamford and Catskill, and 1 hour from Cooperstown or Delhi. In town you’ll feel like you were transported to a quintessential small town America movie set, with a wide Main Street filled with old pickup trucks rolling through and neighbors saying hello to one another. A sweet, wholesome escape.
UNYREIS #R1478650
Aug 11, 2023
Sold
$480,000
$501/sq ft
Jun 20, 2023
Listed
$389,000
$406/sq ft
Global MLS #202130503
Jan 31, 2022
Sold
$120,250
$126/sq ft
Dec 14, 2021
Contingent
—
Oct 13, 2021
Listed
$99,000
$103/sq ft
+13
Ideal weekend or year-round property. With a little TLC you will have a nice home. Off-the-road setting with a level open yard and small stream. Great place to let the kids run around or have family gatherings. Good Condition
Public Records
Jul 28, 1997
Sold
$50,000
$52/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2026
$8,323
$25,400 + $297,600
$323,000
2025
$8,323 (+8.4%)
$25,400 + $297,600
$323,000
2024
$7,680 (+127.7%)
$24,900 + $260,900
$285,800
2023
$3,373 (+68.4%)
$24,400 + $93,100
$117,500
2022
$2,003 (−0.4%)
$19,800 + $35,500
$55,300
2021
$2,012 (−3.0%)
$19,800 + $35,500
$55,300
2020
$2,074 (−0.9%)
$19,800 + $35,500
$55,300
2019
$2,092 (+1.5%)
$19,800 + $35,500
$55,300
2018
$2,062 (+0.7%)
$19,800 + $35,500
$55,300
2017
$2,047 (+1.2%)
$19,800 + $32,900
$52,700
2016
$2,023 (+2.0%)
$19,800 + $32,900
$52,700
2015
$1,982 (−0.7%)
$19,800 + $32,900
$52,700
2014
$1,996
$19,800 + $32,900
$52,700
Tax history for 111 Mattice Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2026
$8,323
$25,400 + $297,600
$323,000
2025
$8,323 (+8.4%)
$25,400 + $297,600
$323,000
2024
$7,680 (+127.7%)
$24,900 + $260,900
$285,800
2023
$3,373 (+68.4%)
$24,400 + $93,100
$117,500
2022
$2,003 (−0.4%)
$19,800 + $35,500
$55,300
2021
$2,012 (−3.0%)
$19,800 + $35,500
$55,300
2020
$2,074 (−0.9%)
$19,800 + $35,500
$55,300
2019
$2,092 (+1.5%)
$19,800 + $35,500
$55,300
2018
$2,062 (+0.7%)
$19,800 + $35,500
$55,300
2017
$2,047 (+1.2%)
$19,800 + $32,900
$52,700
2016
$2,023 (+2.0%)
$19,800 + $32,900
$52,700
2015
$1,982 (−0.7%)
$19,800 + $32,900
$52,700
2014
$1,996
$19,800 + $32,900
$52,700
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.