Charming Ranch Retreat with Endless Possibilities Welcome to your dream home! This captivating 5-bedroom, 3-bath sprawling ranch is the perfect blend of comfort and character, nestled on a beautiful country lot with the potential for a farmette. As you step inside, you’ll be greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere enhanced by unique southwestern touches that create a distinct ambiance. The expansive living spaces are bathed in natural light, showcasing attractive features and thoughtful designs throughout. The heart of the home is a spacious living room, perfect for family gatherings or entertaining friends. Adjacent is a well-appointed kitchen, equipped with ample storage and modern appliances, making meal preparation a breeze. Each of the generously sized bedrooms offers a peaceful retreat, with plenty of closet space to meet all your storage needs; highlighted by 2 expansive walk-in closets in the primary bedroom. The three bathrooms are tastefully designed, offering both style and convenience for the entire family, throughout the home. Outside, the property provides a serene escape with endless possibilities. Imagine peaceful mornings on the patio, and hosting evening gatherings using your outdoor kitchen. There’s the option of tending to your garden and caring for the thoughtfully curated fruit trees while creating your own farmette, complete with space for sustainable homesteading desires and ample acreage for livestock. The gently rolling landscape and mature trees offer natural privacy and a tranquil setting. The heated 3-car garage provides ample space for vehicles and additional storage, making it an ideal workspace for hobbies or projects year-round; and the adjacent outbuilding offers further potential. Conveniently located just minutes from town, you’ll enjoy the best of both worlds—peaceful country living with easy access to shops, dining, and local amenities. Delayed showings begin on May 17, 2025 at 9 AM, Delayed negotiations to begin on May 23, 2025 at 9AM.
Listing by Hunt Real Estate ERA/Columbus, (585) 388-1400
See all
Provided by Redfin
Sale history for 5186 Tellier Rd
Date
Event
Price
UNYREIS #R1605542
Jul 14, 2025
Sold
$400,000
$146/sq ft
May 26, 2025
Pending
—
May 15, 2025
Listed
$449,900
$164/sq ft
UNYREIS #R1372466
Dec 10, 2021
Sold
$364,900
$133/sq ft
Oct 15, 2021
Listed
$364,900
$133/sq ft
Custom Built 3 Bedroom, 3 Bath Ranch on 5.9 Acres of Land! Spacious Great Room w/ Vaulted Ceilings & Sunken Wood Burning Fireplace. Gourmet Kitchen w/ Granite Counters & Breakfast Bar & Walk In Pantry! You Will Enjoy 2 Sun Porches! One Offers a Pellet Stove & Granite Counters, Wet Bar & Beverage Refrigerator, the Other has Baseboard Heat & Electric Wall Fireplace & Sliding Door to Side Yard. Owners Suite Boasts Kiva Fireplace & Sliding Door to Patio. Two Spacious Walk-In Closets & Spa Like Owners En-Suite w/ Soaking Tub & Walk In Shower! Guest Bedroom has Private Entry into Main Bath, As Well as Hallway Entry. Great Craft Room for Your Projects or Use As An Office. Your Going to Love the First Floor Laundry w/ Plenty of Cabinet & Counter Space! 9 ft Ceilings Throughout! Partially Finished Lower Level w/ Walk-out Offers Recreation Room, Bedroom, Full Bath & So Much More! Spend Your Summer Nights on Pergola Covered Patio w/ Outdoor Kitchen, Complete w/ Grill, Smoker, Bev Refrigerator & Sink. Shed & 12x32 Outbuilding for Lawn Equip & Toys! Don't Wait This is a Must SEE Home!!
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2026
$8,875
$34,100 + $361,900
$396,000
2025
$8,875 (−1.1%)
$34,100 + $361,900
$396,000
2024
$8,975 (+2.7%)
$34,100 + $361,900
$396,000
2023
$8,739 (−3.9%)
$16,000 + $205,000
$221,000
2022
$9,090 (+1.9%)
$16,000 + $205,000
$221,000
2021
$8,921 (+20.6%)
$16,000 + $205,000
$221,000
2020
$7,396 (+2.6%)
$16,000 + $205,000
$221,000
2019
$7,209 (+4.9%)
$16,000 + $205,000
$221,000
2018
$6,872 (+3.7%)
$16,000 + $205,000
$221,000
2017
$6,628 (−9.8%)
$16,000 + $205,000
$221,000
2016
$7,347 (+0.6%)
$16,000 + $205,000
$221,000
2015
$7,302 (+2.6%)
$16,000 + $205,000
$221,000
2014
$7,117
$16,000 + $205,000
$221,000
Tax history for 5186 Tellier Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2026
$8,875
$34,100 + $361,900
$396,000
2025
$8,875 (−1.1%)
$34,100 + $361,900
$396,000
2024
$8,975 (+2.7%)
$34,100 + $361,900
$396,000
2023
$8,739 (−3.9%)
$16,000 + $205,000
$221,000
2022
$9,090 (+1.9%)
$16,000 + $205,000
$221,000
2021
$8,921 (+20.6%)
$16,000 + $205,000
$221,000
2020
$7,396 (+2.6%)
$16,000 + $205,000
$221,000
2019
$7,209 (+4.9%)
$16,000 + $205,000
$221,000
2018
$6,872 (+3.7%)
$16,000 + $205,000
$221,000
2017
$6,628 (−9.8%)
$16,000 + $205,000
$221,000
2016
$7,347 (+0.6%)
$16,000 + $205,000
$221,000
2015
$7,302 (+2.6%)
$16,000 + $205,000
$221,000
2014
$7,117
$16,000 + $205,000
$221,000
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.