Whether you are looking for a peaceful weekend retreat or a year round country charmer, you'll find it in this meticulously renovated, professionally decorated circa 1867 farmhouse set on 26 bucolic acres. The property offers a 4 stall horse barn, a milk house that now serves as an office, rolling meadow, lawn & woodland, 2 ponds, waterfalls & a stream. The home, a classic example of early Putnam County homesteads with period details throughout. A true storybook setting just 90 minutes from NYC!
Single-familyProperty Type
1867Year Built
26.05 acresLot Size
$540Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
Listing by Claudia Jiskra• Gillian Stewart Real Estate
Whether you are looking for a peaceful weekend retreat or a year round country charmer, you'll find it in this meticulously renovated, professionally decorated circa 1867 farmhouse set on 26 bucolic acres. The property offers a 4 stall horse barn, a milk house that now serves as an office, rolling meadow, lawn & woodland, 2 ponds, waterfalls & a stream. The home, a classic example of early Putnam County homesteads with period details throughout. A true storybook setting just 90 minutes from NYC!
OneKey® MLS as Distributed by MLS Grid #H3205657
Aug 9, 2012
Sold
$597,500
$296/sq ft
Feb 24, 2012
Listed
$619,000
$306/sq ft
Smart MLS #98501517
Nov 12, 2011
Listing Removed
—
May 17, 2011
Listed
$699,000
$346/sq ft
Public Records
Jul 26, 2007
Sold
$680,000
$337/sq ft
Public Records
Dec 3, 2003
Sold
$730,000
$361/sq ft
Public Records
Jul 1, 2003
Sold
$730,000
$361/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2026
$20,420
$227,600 + $540,300
$767,900
2025
$20,420 (−0.7%)
$227,600 + $540,300
$767,900
2024
$20,565 (+2.0%)
$214,700 + $509,700
$724,400
2023
$20,164 (+1.5%)
$202,500 + $480,900
$683,400
2022
$19,864 (+0.9%)
$164,600 + $429,700
$594,300
2021
$19,688 (+1.3%)
$164,600 + $385,700
$550,300
2020
$19,435 (+1.3%)
$164,600 + $369,700
$534,300
2019
$19,177 (+9.5%)
$164,600 + $355,800
$520,400
2018
$17,509 (+0.8%)
$164,600 + $355,800
$520,400
2017
$17,378 (+4.3%)
$159,500 + $348,200
$507,700
2016
$16,668 (+2.3%)
$147,100 + $348,200
$495,300
2015
$16,298 (−5.6%)
$147,100 + $328,400
$475,500
2014
$17,273 (+8.0%)
$147,100 + $323,700
$470,800
2013
$15,998 (+2.6%)
$147,100 + $343,500
$490,600
2012
$15,590 (−5.0%)
$147,100 + $358,700
$505,800
2011
$16,403 (+272.2%)
$147,100 + $374,300
$521,400
2010
$4,407 (−65.2%)
$147,100 + $401,700
$548,800
2009
$12,652
$147,100 + $411,000
$558,100
Tax history for 500 Bullet Hole Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2026
$20,420
$227,600 + $540,300
$767,900
2025
$20,420 (−0.7%)
$227,600 + $540,300
$767,900
2024
$20,565 (+2.0%)
$214,700 + $509,700
$724,400
2023
$20,164 (+1.5%)
$202,500 + $480,900
$683,400
2022
$19,864 (+0.9%)
$164,600 + $429,700
$594,300
2021
$19,688 (+1.3%)
$164,600 + $385,700
$550,300
2020
$19,435 (+1.3%)
$164,600 + $369,700
$534,300
2019
$19,177 (+9.5%)
$164,600 + $355,800
$520,400
2018
$17,509 (+0.8%)
$164,600 + $355,800
$520,400
2017
$17,378 (+4.3%)
$159,500 + $348,200
$507,700
2016
$16,668 (+2.3%)
$147,100 + $348,200
$495,300
2015
$16,298 (−5.6%)
$147,100 + $328,400
$475,500
2014
$17,273 (+8.0%)
$147,100 + $323,700
$470,800
2013
$15,998 (+2.6%)
$147,100 + $343,500
$490,600
2012
$15,590 (−5.0%)
$147,100 + $358,700
$505,800
2011
$16,403 (+272.2%)
$147,100 + $374,300
$521,400
2010
$4,407 (−65.2%)
$147,100 + $401,700
$548,800
2009
$12,652
$147,100 + $411,000
$558,100
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.