2964 Noyac Rd, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Steeped in Hamptons history and artfully reimagined for contemporary living, this beautifully restored cedar-shake traditional offers a rare blend of provenance, privacy, and purpose. Originally constructed in the late 1700s and meticulously renovated in 2005, the residence retains its historic soul while embracing modern comforts across 3,700 +/- sq. ft. of living space. Set on a shy acre, the property includes a 5-bedroom main house, detached legal guest apartment, 4 full and 2 half baths, a 2-car garage, and a heated pool. Anchored by original architectural details and refined millwork, the interiors unfold with understated elegance. A sweeping curved staircase, period moldings, and three fireplaces serve as graceful reminders of the home’s 18th-century origins. Sunlight pours through near floor-to-ceiling windows, accentuating the symmetry of the traditional layout while creating an airy, inviting flow throughout. The chef’s kitchen is as functional as it is warm, outfitted with a Viking stove, large center island, and abundant storage. Dual dining rooms allow for both casual gatherings and formal entertaining, while multiple living areas offer space to unwind by the fire or gather with guests. The upper level hosts four bedrooms, including a spacious primary suite offering quiet privacy and garden views. Outdoors, the grounds are thoughtfully arranged for both leisure and entertaining. At the center is a 40'x20' heated pool, surrounded by multiple seating areas, mature landscaping, and curated gardens that enhance the peaceful, timeless setting. The legal guest apartment features 1 bedroom, 2 baths, a high-end kitchen, and private living quarters—ideal for hosting extended family or generating rental income. A detached 2-car garage completes the offering. This home’s history is not just architectural, but personal. Once owned by Anna and Detlef Pump—founders of Loaves & Fishes and longtime stewards of Hamptons culture—the property reflects their legacy of elevated simplicity. Detlef, a master stone mason, contributed to some of the most iconic historic restorations across the East End, while Anna’s vision for Loaves & Fishes remains synonymous with Hamptons culinary life, now lovingly continued by their daughter, Sybille. Located moments from East Hampton Village and the ocean beaches, this is a rare opportunity to own a living piece of Hamptons history, one that seamlessly bridges heritage and modern-day luxury.