Off market may 2024 for $765K

$964,785

Est. refi paymentEst. refi $3,756/mo

•

—

sq ft

57 New Mill Rd, Smithtown, NY 11787

About this home

Spacious Betsy Ross Colonial Located on .54 Acre Lot In The Desirable Forestwood Section of Smithtown. Offering A Quiet Residential Neighborhood With Close Proximity To Blydenburgh Park. This Classic Residence Boasts A Welcoming Entry Foyer, Formal Dining Room, Formal Living Room, Family Room With Wood Fireplace, Spacious Updated Eat In Kitchen With Granite Countertops and Stainless Steel Appliances. Laundry Area, Mud Hall and Powder Room All Conveniently Adjacent To 1 Car Garage and Outside Entrance. Upper Level Includes Primary Bedroom Suite With Shower, Walk In Closet, 3 Additional Bedrooms With Jack and Jill Bathroom and Jacuzzi Tub. All Hardwood Flooring as Seen/Carpet As Seen. Spectacular Property Featuring Fenced In-Ground Pool And Patio Area Perfect For Entertaining. Valuable Updates Include Refurbished A/C (2 Years), Updated Heating System (2 Years), New Siding (5 Years), Roof (5 Years). Located Close to Beaches, Golf Clubs, Renowned Restaurants and Park. Smithtown School District., Additional information: Appearance:Diamond,Interior Features:Lr/Dr,Separate Hotwater Heater:Y

Single-familyProperty Type

1966Year Built

0.54 acresLot Size

Listing by Denise Voelker • Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

Bought with Ivan Mijalkovic • Corcoran

Redfin checked: 3 minutes ago

•Source:OneKey® MLS as Distributed by MLS Grid #L3532898

Redfin Estimate

$964,785

$200K since sold in May 2024$4,000 since October

Recently sold homes
Estimate history
Homes for sale

This home's estimate is 19.5% higher than the average sale price ($807K) of 5 comparable homes.

BOUGHT WITH REDFIN OCT 22, 2026
$750,000
A
4 beds3 baths1,870 sq ft
9 Dillmont Dr, Smithtown, NY 11787
Listing by Signature Premier Properties
SOLD MAY 2, 2023
$720,000
B
4 beds2.5 baths2,411 sq ft
19 Eckernkamp Dr, Smithtown, NY 11787
Listing by Howard Hanna Coach
SOLD AUG 11, 2026
$965,000
C
4 beds2.5 baths2,800 sq ft
5 Old Landers Ct, Smithtown, NY 11787
Listing by RE/MAX Integrity Leaders
SOLD JUL 27, 2026
$725,500
D
4 beds2.5 baths2,500 sq ft
23 Whitney Gate, Smithtown, NY 11787
Listing by Realty Connect USA L I Inc
SOLD OCT 16, 2026
$875,000
E
3 beds3 baths2,000 sq ft
7 Carrie Ct, Smithtown, NY 11787
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate

Claim this home to receive a free report every month with insights on the changing estimate.

Earn from this home

Sell

$322,322

Est. take-home

List your home with Redfin and save $9,648

Refinance

Est. cash available

Get cash now or lower your monthly rate

Rent

$3,822/mo

Redfin rental estimate

List your home for rent

Market trends in 11787, NY

Last updated October 2026

Buyer's Market

Seller's Market

Seller's market

Sale-to-list price

104.3%

0.7% MoM

Median sale price

$881K

$7K MoM

Avg. days on market

23d

1 days MoM

Recently sold homes

119

27 MoM

New listings for sale

COMING SOON
$825,000
3 beds3 baths2,403 sq ft
8 Friendly Rd, Smithtown, NY 11787
Listing by American Real Estate Assoc Inc
COMING SOON
$875,000
3 beds1.5 baths— sq ft
143 Oakside Dr, Smithtown, NY 11787
Listing by Howard Hanna Coach
$1,749,990
5 beds3.5 baths3,400 sq ft
3 Greentree Ct, Smithtown, NY 11787
Listing by Signature Premier Properties
$799,999
4 beds2 baths1,975 sq ft
67 Morewood Dr, Smithtown, NY 11787
Listing by Compass Greater NY LLC
$1,199,999
4 beds2.5 baths2,727 sq ft
4 Magnolia Ln, Smithtown, NY 11787
Listing by Coldwell Banker American Homes
$945,000
5 beds3 baths2,965 sq ft
24 S Lot Rd, Smithtown, NY 11787
Listing by Coldwell Banker American Homes
$849,000
3 beds2.5 baths1,600 sq ft
4 6th Ave, Smithtown, NY 11787
Listing by Compass Greater NY LLC
COMING SOON
$649,999
4 beds2 baths1,671 sq ft
78 Ridge Rd, Smithtown, NY 11787
Listing by Century Homes Realty Group LLC
$819,999
4 beds2.5 baths2,100 sq ft
22 Sheryl Cres, Smithtown, NY 11787
Listing by Signature Premier Properties
$798,000
5 beds3.5 baths2,265 sq ft
77 Juniper Ave, Smithtown, NY 11787
Listing by Island Edge Homes
See all

Provided by Redfin

Sale history for 57 New Mill Rd

Year

Property tax

Land + Additions

Assessment*

2026

$19,886

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2025

$19,886 (+4.1%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2024

$19,098 (+2.6%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2023

$18,620 (+2.8%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2022

$18,105

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2021

$18,105 (+1.6%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2020

$17,819 (−7.0%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2019

$19,165 (+26.9%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2018

$15,100 (+1.1%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2017

$14,936 (+1.2%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2016

$14,761 (+3.1%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2015

$14,311 (+2.2%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2014

$14,004 (+3.6%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2013

$13,518 (+2.1%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2012

$13,237 (+5.4%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2011

$12,560 (+2.0%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2010

$12,308 (+0.3%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2009

$12,273

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

Tax history for 57 New Mill Rd

Year

Property tax

Land + Additions

Assessment*

2026

$19,886

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2025

$19,886 (+4.1%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2024

$19,098 (+2.6%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2023

$18,620 (+2.8%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2022

$18,105

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2021

$18,105 (+1.6%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2020

$17,819 (−7.0%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2019

$19,165 (+26.9%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2018

$15,100 (+1.1%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2017

$14,936 (+1.2%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2016

$14,761 (+3.1%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2015

$14,311 (+2.2%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2014

$14,004 (+3.6%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2013

$13,518 (+2.1%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2012

$13,237 (+5.4%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2011

$12,560 (+2.0%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2010

$12,308 (+0.3%)

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

2009

$12,273

$500 + $6,745

$7,245

*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.

Public record

Beds

Baths

Stories

—

Lot width

—

Lot depth

—

Lot size

0.54 Acres

Year renovated

—

Sq. Ft.

2,251

Year built

1966

Style

Single Family Residential

County

Suffolk County

APN

0800100000100008000

Parking Spaces

—

Basement

—

Accessible

—

HOA Dues

—

Garage

—

Features

—

Last updated by owner on Aug 31, 2026.

Property details

Parking

Parking Information
Parking Features: Attached, Private

Interior

Fireplace Information
Has Fireplace
Fireplaces Total: 1

Heating & Cooling
Cooling: Central Air
Heating: Baseboard, Oil

Interior Features
Interior Features: Eat-in Kitchen,Entrance Foyer,Formal Dining,Granite Counters,Primary Bathroom,Walk-In Closet(s)
Appliances: Oil Water Heater
Flooring: Carpet, Hardwood
Patio And Porch Features: Patio

Room Information
Room Description: Formal Living Room with Bay Window||Family Room with Wood Burning Fireplace||Dedicated Dining Area||Eat In Kitchen||Powder Room||Laundry Area Washer/Dryer||Primary En-Suite with Shower||Bedroom 2||Bedroom 3||Bedroom 4||Jack and Jill with Jacuzzi Tub
Basement YN: No
Attic: Scuttle
Rooms Total: 8
Basement: Full, Unfinished
Additional Rooms: Library/Den

Bathroom Information
Bathrooms Full: 2
Bathrooms Half: 1

Exterior

Exterior Features
Construction Materials: Frame, Stone, Vinyl Siding
Fencing: Fenced

Pool Information
Has Private Pool
Pool Features: In Ground

Lot Information
Additional Parcels YN: No
Lot Features: Sprinklers In Front, Sprinklers In Rear
Zoning: Residential

Property Information
Property Sub Type: Single Family Residence

Financial

Tax Information
Tax Section: 100
Tax Annual Amount: $18,619.78

Utilities

Utility Information
Sewer: Cesspool
Utilities: Trash Collection Public

Location

School Information
Middle Or Junior School: Accompsett Middle School
High School: Smithtown High School-West
High School District: Smithtown

Location Information
Directions: Brooksite to 57 New Mill Road
County Or Parish: Suffolk County

Public facts

Beds: 4
Baths: 2.0
Sq. Ft.: 2,251
Stories: —
Lot Size: 0.54 acres
Style: Single Family Residential
Year Built: 1966
Year Renovated: —
County: Suffolk County
APN: 0800100000100008000

Home facts updated by county records on Aug 31, 2026

Around this home

Schools

K - 12
Preschool & daycare

Smithtown Elementary School

Public K-5 • Assigned • 1.3mi

7/10

Accompsett Middle School

Public 6-8 • Assigned • 1.5mi

7/10

Smithtown High School West

Public 9-12 • Assigned • 1.6mi

10/10

Provided by GreatSchools

Lifestyle

Provided by Walk Score and Local Logic

Climate risks

1/10 Flood Factor

Minimal risk of a flood reaching the building in the next 30 years

1/10 Fire Factor

Unlikely to be in a wildfire in next 30 years

5/10 Heat Factor

7 days above 95° expected this year, 16 days in 30 years

8/10 Wind Factor

80% chance of strong winds in next 30 years

4/10 Air Factor

3 unhealthy days expected this year, 5 days in 30 years

Provided by First Street

Historical weather

Smithtown, NY • 11787

Average low and high temperatures (°F)

Jan

Feb

Mar

Apr

May

Jun

Jul

Aug

Sep

Oct

Nov

Dec

Sun exposure

In this area, properties receive around 8.8 hours in June and 4.5 hours in December, placing it below the U.S. average for solar exposure.

8.8 hrs

4.5 hrs

JuneDecember

Provided by Shadowmap

Estimated sale price

$917,000 – $1.11M

Reach more buyers when you sell with Redfin. Save up to $9,648 in fees. 3 minutes to get started.

Need the cash from your home fast? Sell to .

Nearby similar homes

$798,000

5 beds3.5 baths2,265 sq ft

77 Juniper Ave, Smithtown, NY 11787

Fully renovated home • Formal living room • Elegant dining room

Listing by Island Edge Homes

3D WALKTHROUGH

$989,999

4 beds2.5 baths2,590 sq ft

14 Sandpiper Ct, Smithtown, NY 11787

Warm wood flooring • Granite countertops • Tiered breakfast bar

Listing by Signature Premier Properties

$749,999

3 beds2.5 baths1,650 sq ft

153 Juniper Ave, Smithtown, NY 11787

Mature landscaping • Oversized driveway • Inviting front porch

Listing by Coldwell Banker American Homes

FOR SALE BY OWNER

$865,000

5 beds3 baths1,975 sq ft

39 Sheryl Cres, Smithtown, NY 11787

0.31 acre lot • Built 1966 • Listed 158 days

$919,000

4 beds3 baths1,986 sq ft

57 Brooksite Dr, Smithtown, NY 11787

Finished basement • Attached garage • 0.5 acre lot

Listing by Realty Executives Today

$1,890,000

4 beds2.5 baths3,211 sq ft

225 Old Willets Path, Smithtown, NY 11787

Oak hardwood floors • Custom millwork • 1 acre lot

Listing by Long Island Homes & Horse Prop

New listings for sale in 11787

COMING SOON

$825,000

3 beds3 baths2,403 sq ft

8 Friendly Rd, Smithtown, NY 11787

0.32 acre lot • Garage • Built 1977

Listing by American Real Estate Assoc Inc

COMING SOON

$875,000

3 beds1.5 baths— sq ft

143 Oakside Dr, Smithtown, NY 11787

Full acre • Unique third bedroom • Separate home office

Listing by Howard Hanna Coach

$1,749,990

5 beds3.5 baths3,400 sq ft

3 Greentree Ct, Smithtown, NY 11787

New construction • Cul-de-sac • Landscaped half-acre

Listing by Signature Premier Properties

$799,999

4 beds2 baths1,975 sq ft

67 Morewood Dr, Smithtown, NY 11787

Updated hi-ranch • Spacious front lawn • Long driveway

Listing by Compass Greater NY LLC

$1,199,999

4 beds2.5 baths2,727 sq ft

4 Magnolia Ln, Smithtown, NY 11787

Built-in wet bar • 0.5 acre lot • 2 garage spots

Listing by Coldwell Banker American Homes

$945,000

5 beds3 baths2,965 sq ft

24 S Lot Rd, Smithtown, NY 11787

Formal living room • Dining room • Sunroom

Listing by Coldwell Banker American Homes

$849,000

3 beds2.5 baths1,600 sq ft

4 6th Ave, Smithtown, NY 11787

Open floor plan • Updated kitchen • Sliding glass doors

Listing by Compass Greater NY LLC

COMING SOON

$649,999

4 beds2 baths1,671 sq ft

78 Ridge Rd, Smithtown, NY 11787

Two car garage • Expansive driveway • Mature landscaping

Listing by Century Homes Realty Group LLC

$819,999

4 beds2.5 baths2,100 sq ft

22 Sheryl Cres, Smithtown, NY 11787

Hardwood floors • Cathedral ceiling • Bay window

Listing by Signature Premier Properties

Home values near 57 New Mill Rd

Data from public records.

Address	Redfin Estimate
58 New Mill Road, Smithtown, NY 4 Beds \| 2.5 Baths \| 2292 Sq. Ft.	$890,179
60 New Mill Road, Smithtown, NY 4 Beds \| 2.5 Baths \| 1950 Sq. Ft.	$874,922
65 New Mill Road, Smithtown, NY 4 Beds \| 3.5 Baths \| 2722 Sq. Ft.	$1,046,577
63 New Mill Road, Smithtown, NY 4 Beds \| 3 Baths \| - Sq. Ft.	$1,072,936
8 Sandpiper Court, Smithtown, NY 4 Beds \| 2 Baths \| 2242 Sq. Ft.	$922,645
12 Sandpiper Court, Smithtown, NY 5 Beds \| 3.5 Baths \| 3669 Sq. Ft.	$1,129,760
17 Sandpiper Court, Smithtown, NY 4 Beds \| 2 Baths \| 2042 Sq. Ft.	$921,012

Address	Redfin Estimate
59 New Mill Road, Smithtown, NY 4 Beds \| 2 Baths \| 2400 Sq. Ft.	$971,857
53 New Mill Road, Smithtown, NY 4 Beds \| 2 Baths \| 2251 Sq. Ft.	$885,725
52 New Mill Road, Smithtown, NY 4 Beds \| 2.5 Baths \| 1950 Sq. Ft.	$900,211
9 Sandpiper Court, Smithtown, NY 5 Beds \| 3.5 Baths \| 2458 Sq. Ft.	$1,040,857
3 Sandpiper Court, Smithtown, NY 5 Beds \| 3 Baths \| 2400 Sq. Ft.	$908,387
45 Mark Drive, Smithtown, NY 4 Beds \| 2.5 Baths \| - Sq. Ft.	$953,689
10 Sandpiper Court, Smithtown, NY 4 Beds \| 2.5 Baths \| 2251 Sq. Ft.	$958,245

Address	Redfin Estimate
61 New Mill Road, Smithtown, NY 4 Beds \| 3 Baths \| 2128 Sq. Ft.	$931,912
54 New Mill Road, Smithtown, NY 5 Beds \| 2.5 Baths \| 2070 Sq. Ft.	$902,800
48 New Mill Road, Smithtown, NY 3 Beds \| 2.5 Baths \| 2185 Sq. Ft.	$887,670
49 Mark Drive, Smithtown, NY 4 Beds \| 2.5 Baths \| - Sq. Ft.	$932,625
14 Sandpiper Court, Smithtown, NY 4 Beds \| 2.5 Baths \| 2590 Sq. Ft.	—
47 Mark Drive, Smithtown, NY 4 Beds \| 2.5 Baths \| - Sq. Ft.	$902,475
6 Sandpiper Court, Smithtown, NY 4 Beds \| 2 Baths \| 2128 Sq. Ft.	$906,353

Property information provided by OneKey® MLS as Distributed by MLS Grid when last listed in 2024. This data may not match . Learn more.

More real estate resources

Neighborhoods
Cities
Zip Codes
Minor Civil Divisions
Popular Searches

Long Island homes for sale

Download the Redfin App on the Apple App Store

Download the Redfin App from the Google Play Store

Join us

Become an Agent

Get referrals

Careers

Find homes faster

About us

Find us

Subsidiaries

Affiliated Business

Countries

United States

Canada

Updated September 2025: By searching, you agree to the Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.

Do not sell or share my personal information.

REDFIN and all REDFIN variants, WALK SCORE, and the R logos, are trademarks of Redfin Corporation, registered or pending in the USPTO.

Redfin Brokerage Licenses

California DRE #01521930

Redfin is licensed to do business in New York as Redfin Real Estate. NY Standard Operating Procedures

New Mexico Real Estate Licenses

TREC: Info About Brokerage Services, Consumer Protection Notice

All mortgage lending products and information are provided by Rocket Mortgage, LLC | NMLS #3030; www.NMLSConsumerAccess.org. Licensed in 50 states. This site is not authorized by the New York State Department of Financial Services for mortgage solicitation or loan applications activities related to properties located in the State of New York.

Redfin Corporation is an affiliated business of Rocket Limited Partnership. Each company, and their subsidiaries, are separate legal entities operated and managed through its own management and governance structures.

If you are using a screen reader, or having trouble reading this website, please call Redfin Customer Support for help at 1-844-759-7732.

REDFIN IS COMMITTED TO AND ABIDES BY THE FAIR HOUSING ACT AND EQUAL OPPORTUNITY ACT. READ REDFIN'S FAIR HOUSING POLICY AND THE NEW YORK STATE FAIR HOUSING NOTICE.

GreatSchools Ratings provided by GreatSchools.org.

11754 homes for sale
11725 homes for sale
11780 homes for sale
11787 homes for sale
11788 homes for sale

Wilton homes for sale
Weston homes for sale
Fairfield homes for sale
Easton homes for sale
New Canaan homes for sale

Houses for rent in Smithtown	Agents near me	White Plains, NY homes for sale	Smithtown Housing Market
Houses for sale near me	New York, NY homes for sale	Yonkers, NY homes for sale
Land for sale near me	Manhattan, NY homes for sale	Scarsdale, NY homes for sale
Open Houses near me	Rochester, NY homes for sale	Smithtown Property Records
Condos for sale near me	Buffalo, NY homes for sale	NY New Listings

Greenwich homes for sale
Stamford homes for sale
Norwalk homes for sale