Est. $1,911 per month, based on comparable rentals
Sale and tax history for 74 Onderdonk Rd
Sale History
Tax History
Date
Event
Price
OneKey® MLS as Distributed by MLS Grid #953141
Jun 17, 2026
Sold
$452,000
$444/sq ft
Apr 27, 2026
Pending
—
Mar 1, 2026
Listed
$437,000
$430/sq ft
OneKey® MLS as Distributed by MLS Grid #907552
Nov 14, 2025
Sold
$437,000
$430/sq ft
Oct 7, 2025
Pending
—
Sep 7, 2025
Listed
$425,000
$418/sq ft
ENCHANTING COUNTRY COTTAGE nestled in the heart of Warwick, NY - this timeless treasure sits on nearly 3 acres of rolling meadow with serene mountain views, specimen trees and is just 55 miles to NYC. A true blend of charm and comfort, the clapboard and stone exterior sets the stage for a home rich in history and character. Both inside and out, this home feels like it leapt from the pages of a fairy tale at every turn. Inside, you’ll find glowing hardwood floors, original woodwork, an inviting open living/dining area anchored by a magnificent wood burning fireplace and large picture window framing the meadow with its abundant flora and fauna. Double Dutch doors open onto a generous fieldstone patio—perfect for morning coffee, al fresco dining, or simply soaking in the serene landscape. The cheerful red and white kitchen, straight out of Country Living magazine, connects easily to the attached one car garage and laundry, making daily life seamless and practical. Upstairs, two inviting bedrooms each feature roomy closets and peaceful views of the surrounding fields and mountains. With spaces designed for quiet reading, creative work, and daydreaming, this cottage feels both restorative and inspiring. Enjoy strolling the large bee balm based meadow and the company of oak trees, an impressive specimen of black walnut, white pines, eastern red cedar and sumac surround the meadow forming a small woodland amidst their canopy. Rock walls and rock outcroppings add story and substance. Set along a quiet country road yet just minutes to the heart of Warwick’s beloved village, this is a home where history, beauty, and ease come together. Easy access to major grocery stores and services as well as public transportation to NYC, Woodbury Common Premium Outlets and major highways. This is a special opportunity to own a piece of Warwick's legendary history and an alluring place to call home.
HGMLS #4525942
Aug 27, 2015
Sold
$233,500
$230/sq ft
Aug 27, 2015
Price Changed
$233,500
$230/sq ft
Jul 10, 2015
Contingent
—
Jul 10, 2015
Price Changed
$239,500
$235/sq ft
Jun 5, 2015
Listed
$239,500
$235/sq ft
This 1895 home nestled in a quiet, private neighborhood has been thoughtfully and beautifully renovated while still enjoying its original special character as you are surrounded by nature on all sides. 2.8 private wooded acres scattered with wonderful rock formations and numerous specimen plantings. The perfect spot to return to at the end of a hectic day. From the moment you step foot into the open 1.5 story foyer you will long to kick your shoes off and relax in front of a fire or listen to music as you gaze at the spectacular views right from your large family room. All bedrooms are large in size with hardwood floors throughout the bedrooms and the home. 1 car garage that can also be used for storage. Only 5 minutes to the exclusive Warwick School District. Come and see this now!
OneKey® MLS as Distributed by MLS Grid #H4525942
Aug 27, 2015
Sold
$233,500
$230/sq ft
Jun 5, 2015
Listed
$239,500
$235/sq ft
Public Records
Jul 27, 2010
Sold
$158,500
$156/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2026
$6,290
$15,900 + $10,700
$26,600
2025
$6,290 (+1.8%)
$15,900 + $10,700
$26,600
2024
$6,179 (+2.0%)
$15,900 + $10,700
$26,600
2023
$6,055 (+1.9%)
$15,900 + $10,700
$26,600
2022
$5,944 (−1.3%)
$15,900 + $10,700
$26,600
2021
$6,020 (+0.1%)
$15,900 + $10,700
$26,600
2020
$6,012 (+1.8%)
$15,900 + $10,700
$26,600
2019
$5,908 (+2.6%)
$15,900 + $10,700
$26,600
2018
$5,757 (+2.2%)
$15,900 + $10,700
$26,600
2017
$5,632 (+1.9%)
$15,900 + $10,700
$26,600
2016
$5,527 (+25.2%)
$15,900 + $10,700
$26,600
2015
$4,414 (+4.1%)
$15,900 + $10,700
$26,600
2014
$4,239
$15,900 + $10,700
$26,600
Public record
Beds
2
Baths
1
Stories
1.5
Lot width
—
Lot depth
—
Lot size
2.8 Acres
Year renovated
1941
Sq. Ft.
1,017
Year built
1895
Style
Single Family Residential
County
Orange County
APN
335489A04100000010380000000
Parking Spaces
—
Basement
—
Accessible
—
HOA Dues
—
Garage
—
Features
—
Last updated by owner on Oct 8, 2026.
Property details
Parking
Parking Information
Carport YN: No
Parking Features: Attached, Driveway, Off Street, Private