Welcome to your dream waterfront home, a stunning 4,500 square foot Dutch Colonial gem, built in 1936 and overflowing with sumptuous old world charm. Situated on one of the most prestigious streets on the south shore, this residence artfully blends historical elegance with modern luxury. Storybook-like curb appeal greets you upon arrival, highlighted by the stunning 350 sq ft lemonade porch, a grand and inviting area framed by impressive large columns. This area radiates an air of elegance and warmth, setting the stage for the home's welcoming charm. Beyond this splendid outdoor space, the subtly yet invitingly positioned main entry door leads into an interior adorned with rich hardwood floors, elaborate custom moldings, millwork, and elegant wainscoting prevalent in nearly every room. Large Andersen windows throughout the house further enhance its beauty, bathing each room in natural light and creating a bright, cheerful ambiance. First Floor: Here you'll find hardwood floors, oversized windows, wainscoting adorning every room, echoing its historical heritage. Just off the entryway, a sophisticated study with raised custom wood panels and French doors offers privacy. The spacious living room is anchored by a charming wood-burning fireplace, evoking a bygone era. The heart of the home is the elegant granite chef's kitchen, equipped with a large center island, custom cabinets, and top-of-the-line stainless steel appliances, including a Viking gas stove top, double Wolf ovens, and a Sub-Zero refrigerator. A formal dining room and an oversized family room with cathedral ceilings, floor-to-ceiling windows, and a cozy gas fireplace complete the first floor. Second Floor: The luxurious master suite is a private haven with large bedroom windows offering dual water views, a walk-in closet, and a beautiful master bathroom with a custom shower, double vanity, and free-standing soaking tub. Three additional bedrooms and a custom-tiled guest bathroom add to the home's old-world allure. Third Floor: A billiards room and lounge area with captivating water views await for entertainment and relaxation, showcasing the home's multi-level charm. Outdoor Oasis: Experience a blend of luxury and tranquility in the rear yard, featuring 90 feet of canal frontage with a 20 x 40 boat slip w/100 amp service and a private beach. The second-floor balcony deck overlooks the canal. Below, a heated saltwater pool complete with a waterfall, hot tub, and a koi pond create a peaceful retreat. Above the detached garage is a versatile space with expansive water views, perfect as a guest suite or home office. Below, a cozy outdoor bar under the deck is ideal for relaxed gatherings, epitomizing the charm of waterfront living. Waterfront Living: Just 500' from your boat to the Great South Bay, this property invites you to experience waterfront living at its finest, enriched by the unique character of a home built in 1936. Don't miss the opportunity to make 223 West Islip Road your new home., Additional information: Appearance:Mint,Separate Hotwater Heater:Y
Single-familyProperty Type
1936Year Built
0.39 acresLot Size
$451Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
Listing by Brad Wilson• Jones Hollow Realty Group Inc
Bought with Jeanne De Frisco• Netter Real Estate Inc
This Remarkable Waterfront Dutch Colonial Is Set On One Of West Islip's Most Desirable Streets. Originally Built In 1936 And Dramatically Expanded And Restored In 1998. Elegant Chef's Kitchen With Large Center Isle & All Top Line Appliances. Extensive Paver Driveway & Ample Multi Level Trex Decking. 20 X 40 Boat Slip W/ 100 Amp Service, Private Beach., Additional information: Appearance:Superb!,Separate Hotwater Heater:Gas
Public Records
Jan 2, 2007
Sold
$1,130,000
$251/sq ft
Public Records
Mar 8, 1995
Sold
$310,000
$69/sq ft
Public Records
Dec 17, 1991
Sold
$325,000
$72/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2026
$26,529
$22,500 + $62,500
$85,000
2025
$26,529 (+3.4%)
$22,500 + $62,500
$85,000
2024
$25,645 (+14.0%)
$22,500 + $62,500
$85,000
2017
$22,500 (−0.3%)
$22,500 + $62,500
$85,000
2016
$22,562 (−1.3%)
$22,500 + $62,500
$85,000
2015
$22,849 (+25.8%)
$22,500 + $62,500
$85,000
2014
$18,170 (−16.0%)
$22,500 + $46,010
$68,510
2013
$21,642 (+2.9%)
$22,500 + $62,500
$85,000
2012
$21,024 (+5.3%)
$22,500 + $62,500
$85,000
2011
$19,973 (+4.1%)
$22,500 + $62,500
$85,000
2010
$19,188 (+1.4%)
$22,500 + $62,500
$85,000
2009
$18,930
$22,500 + $62,500
$85,000
Tax history for 223 W Islip Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2026
$26,529
$22,500 + $62,500
$85,000
2025
$26,529 (+3.4%)
$22,500 + $62,500
$85,000
2024
$25,645 (+14.0%)
$22,500 + $62,500
$85,000
2017
$22,500 (−0.3%)
$22,500 + $62,500
$85,000
2016
$22,562 (−1.3%)
$22,500 + $62,500
$85,000
2015
$22,849 (+25.8%)
$22,500 + $62,500
$85,000
2014
$18,170 (−16.0%)
$22,500 + $46,010
$68,510
2013
$21,642 (+2.9%)
$22,500 + $62,500
$85,000
2012
$21,024 (+5.3%)
$22,500 + $62,500
$85,000
2011
$19,973 (+4.1%)
$22,500 + $62,500
$85,000
2010
$19,188 (+1.4%)
$22,500 + $62,500
$85,000
2009
$18,930
$22,500 + $62,500
$85,000
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.