There are homes that when you walk thru the door you wished the walls could talk and this is THAT HOME! This is a must see Historic home that won’t disappoint from the moment you step through the front door-you will immediately feel transported back to a different time -one of wide planked hardwood floors, built in book cases, rooms upon rooms with beautiful hand painted woodwork, the deepest windowsills with amazing views out every window! The front winding staircase leads you to super spacious upstairs with three large bright and sunny bedrooms with attached “sitting rooms” or amazing private lounges/closets-leading to the “back” staircase taking you back down to main floor into the modernized galley kitchen. Surrounded by gorgeous farmland and views, this home was recently separated from a larger parcel but retained almost 3 scenic acres, and an amazing 38x100 Wells barn that only lends to this one of a kind property-all of which would be almost impossible to recreate in this day and age! Located at the very end of Guthrie Road you will enjoy the beautiful winding pretty drive up to the property, the grounds are nicely landscaped with a garden and fenced in in-ground pool and patio to enjoy the sunny summer days ahead! The opportunities that this amazing home holds from your very own private residence or entrepreneurial bed and breakfast or Airbnb-this home has been lovingly cared for AND updated throughout the years so you can move in and immediately start creating your own history! There will be delayed negotiations until Monday March 31st at 5:00 to allow everyone the opportunity to visit a true historic homestead!
Single-familyProperty Type
1900Year Built
96.8 acresLot Size
$181Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
1 car garageParking
Listing by Lynn Bezon• Reliant Real Estate
•585-344-4663 (broker)
•accounting@andrewyoung.com (broker)
Contact: 585-746-6253
Bought with Michael Robinson• WNY Metro Roberts Realty
Listing by Keller Williams Realty Greater Rochester
Claim this home to receive a free report every month with insights on the changing estimate.
Earn from this home
Sell
$274,930
Est. take-home
List your home with Redfin and save $6,090
Refinance
$0
Est. cash available
Get cash now or lower your monthly rate
Rent
$2,568/mo
Redfin rental estimate
List your home for rent
Market trends in Scottsville, NY
Last updated October 2026
Buyer's Market
Seller's Market
Balanced market
Sale-to-list price
116.2%
4.1% MoM
Median sale price
$275K
$191 MoM
Avg. days on market
7d
2 days MoM
Recently sold homes
5
2 MoM
Provided by Redfin
Sale history for 256 Guthrie Rd
Date
Event
Price
WNYREIS #B1594898
Aug 7, 2025
Sold
$380,000
$113/sq ft
May 1, 2025
Pending
—
Apr 8, 2025
Relisted
—
Mar 24, 2025
Listed
$399,900
$119/sq ft
Public Records
Oct 30, 2023
Sold
$1,075,000
$320/sq ft
UNYREIS #R1474442
Oct 13, 2023
Sold
$2,000,000
$595/sq ft
Jul 10, 2023
Pending
—
May 30, 2023
Listed
$2,000,000
$595/sq ft
Spanning more than 300 acres, The Guthrie Homestead, established in the 1830's, is a one-of-a-kind property boasting a Limestone (Tufa) Main Residence, a 1788 sq ft Guest House, 50 acre Federal Wildlife Preserve, a 38x100 historically significant Wells Barn, 200+ tillable acres, woods, 2nd barn, outbuildings and a gorgeous inground pool. The beautiful 3200 sq ft Main House has retained much of it's historic charm with oak and pine floors, fireplaces, original doors/hardware. The stately Formal Dining and Living Rooms with pale wood trim, deep window sills, fireplaces and plank floors are reminiscent of a more gentile era. Built in bookcases and lovely white wood trim make the cozy office the perfect 1st floor hide-a-way. Two of the main bedrooms on the second floor have attached "bonus room" (auxiliary bedrooms, dressing rooms, walk-in closets, lounges). Add a bath to the third bedroom which has a private living room and stairs to the kitchen, to have a self contained suite. The Guest House has 4/5 bedrooms and 2.5 baths with great potential as a 1st floor in-law or B+B suites. This Unique property could be the Homestead investment opportunity you've been looking for.
As the MLS and public records start to fill up, we'll list the details here.
Appliances: Double Oven, Dishwasher, Exhaust Fan, Microwave, Propane Water Heater, Refrigerator, Range Hood
Interior Features
Window Features: Drapes
Flooring: Carpet, Hardwood, Varies
Other Features: Den, Entrance Foyer, Galley Kitchen, Home Office, Other, See Remarks, Natural Woodwork, Window Treatments, Bedroom on Main Level, Convertible Bedroom
Exterior
Building Information
Stories: 2
Stories (Total): 2
Year Built Details: Existing
Roof Details: Asphalt, Metal
Construction Details: Stone, Wood Siding, Copper Plumbing
Exterior Features
Exterior Features: Gravel Driveway, Pool, Patio, Propane Tank - Leased
Patio And Porch Features: Patio
Other Structures: Barn(s), Outbuilding
Pool and Spa Information
Pool Features: In Ground
Lot Information
Lot Size Area: 2.88
Lot Size Acres: 2.88
Lot Features: Agricultural, Irregular Lot
Road Frontage Type: Private Road
Property Information
Foundation Details: Block, Stone
Resale
Financial
Assessments and Fees
Assessed Value: $595,800
Tax Information
Annual Tax Amount: $16,431
Utilities
Utility Information
Utilities: High Speed Internet Available
Electric: Circuit Breakers
Sewer: Septic Tank
Water Source: Well
Heating & Cooling
Cooling: Zoned
Has Heating
Heating: Propane, Wood, Zoned, Baseboard, Hot Water
Public facts
Beds: 3
Baths: 1.5
Sq. Ft.: 3,362
Stories: 2.0
Lot Size: 2.88 acres
Style: Single Family Residential
Year Built: 1900
Year Renovated: —
County: Monroe County
APN: 265689A2090300001003100
Home facts updated by county records on Aug 19, 2026
Around this home
Schools
K - 12
Preschool & daycare
Caledonia Mumford Elementary School
Public PreK-5 • Assigned • 0.4mi
4/10
Caledonia Mumford Junior Senior High School
Public 6-12 • Assigned • 0.4mi
8/10
Provided by GreatSchools
Lifestyle
Provided by Walk Score and Local Logic
Historical weather
Mumford, NY • 14511
Average low and high temperatures (°F)
29°
18°
32°
18°
51°
30°
59°
39°
66°
47°
79°
60°
84°
64°
80°
57°
76°
51°
62°
42°
49°
35°
37°
23°
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
Sun exposure
In this area, properties receive around 9.6 hours in
June and 2.4 hours in December, placing it below the
U.S. average for solar exposure.
9.6 hrs
2.4 hrs
JuneDecember
Provided by Shadowmap
Estimated sale price
$579,000 – $701,000
Reach more buyers when you sell with Redfin. Save up to $6,090 in fees.3 minutes to get started.
Get a free, detailed breakdown of how we calculated your estimate.