Fairytale Cottage Retreat on 12.53 Acres with Historic Charm & Modern Comforts. Tucked away in a serene woodland setting, this beautifully restored 1840 stone cottage offers a rare blend of historic character and thoughtful updates. Nestled on 12.53 private acres, this storybook home is a peaceful retreat where every detail has been lovingly curated to inspire tranquility and timeless charm. Inside, you'll find wide-plank brushed oak floors anchored by hand-forged rose-head nails, adding authentic period character. The open-concept kitchen and dining area flow effortlessly to a scenic stone patio, perfect for meals and entertaining with sweeping views of the natural landscape, including two spring-fed ponds ideal for swimming, or quiet reflection. Wander the grounds and you'll discover a unique stone bridge. For the creative or hands-on hobbyist, the super-insulated, heated garage/workshop offers an exceptional space for woodworking, metalworking, or studio use—with a finished bonus room above. Throughout the home, you’ll also find ample hidden storage integrated into the design—ensuring a clean, uncluttered aesthetic without sacrificing functionality. This home is a must see with so much to offer and an assumable loan with 3.125% interest. Whether you're seeking a weekend escape or a forever home, this one-of-a-kind property offers a lifestyle of peace, privacy, and enduring beauty. Your woodland sanctuary awaits. Has accepted an offer with a 5 day bump clause home contingency
Single-familyProperty Type
1840Year Built
12.53 acresLot Size
$239Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
3 car garageParking
Listing by Joni Bates• Marble Key Realty LLC
•315-783-0191 (broker)
•marblekeyrealty@gmail.com (broker)
Bought with Brittney Umstead• Realty by the River, Inc.
Have you been searching for your quiet and peaceful Fairytale Cottage in the Woods? Look no further, this beautifully restored circa 1840 stone home, set on 12.53 acres, offers the perfect retreat for those seeking to unwind and reconnect with nature. As you step inside, you'll feel immediately enveloped in warmth and tranquility. The home features exquisite brushed oak floors and handcrafted rose-head nails, reflecting the care taken to preserve its historic character while incorporating modern comforts. The open-concept dining area and kitchen lead to a patio with stunning views of the grounds, including two picturesque ponds—ideal for outdoor entertaining. Explore the property and discover a stone bridge, a favorite spot for wedding photos. Whether you fish, swim, or simply relax by the ponds, the natural beauty is unmatched. For hobbyists, the heated, super-insulated garage is perfect for woodworking or metalworking, with a finished room above. Experience the serenity and charm of this one-of-a-kind property—your peaceful sanctuary awaits. Assumable VA mortgage, interest rate 3.125%.
CNYIS #S1325490
Aug 25, 2021
Sold
$355,000
$191/sq ft
Mar 22, 2021
Listed
$360,000
$193/sq ft
Are you ready to escape to a quieter way of life, leaving city life behind? This lovingly and artistically rebuilt, circa 1840 stone home situated on 12.53 acres in Oxbow, a small hamlet of Antwerp, is perfect for the person looking to unwind, unplug, kick back and savor some me time. The minute you walk into the home you will be enveloped with a feeling of warmth, peace & contentment. Notice the brushed oak floors with handmade rose head nails. Supreme care was taken during the restoration to maintain the historic nature of the home while sparing no expense inside & out. The open dining area & kitchen has a door leading out to the patio overlooking the beautiful grounds complete with 2 ponds, the perfect set up for entertaining. Take a walk through the grounds & enjoy features such as the stone bridge where many wedding photos have been taken. This is truly one of a kind property. Enjoy the two ponds, fish, swim or just sit back and enjoy the sights and sounds of nature. If you like to tinker check out the super insulated and heated garage, one side set up for wood working and the other for metal work. There is a finished room up over the garage. Peace & serenity can be yours.
CNYIS #S1273035
Oct 31, 2020
Listing Removed
—
Jun 18, 2020
Listed
$350,000
$188/sq ft
CNYIS #S1191326
Oct 24, 2019
Listing Removed
—
May 4, 2019
Listed
$350,000
$188/sq ft
CNYIS #S313974
Dec 20, 2014
Listing Removed
—
Jun 20, 2014
Listed
$369,000
$198/sq ft
CNYIS #S299938
Apr 1, 2014
Listing Removed
—
Oct 1, 2013
Listed
$395,000
$212/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2026
$2,959
$25,300 + $125,500
$150,800
2025
$2,959 (+6.3%)
$25,300 + $125,500
$150,800
2024
$2,783 (+1.9%)
$25,300 + $125,500
$150,800
2023
$2,730 (+0.9%)
$25,300 + $125,500
$150,800
2022
$2,705 (−6.5%)
$25,300 + $125,500
$150,800
2021
$2,894 (−1.3%)
$25,300 + $125,500
$150,800
2020
$2,932 (+1.4%)
$25,300 + $125,500
$150,800
2019
$2,893 (−2.7%)
$25,300 + $125,500
$150,800
2018
$2,972 (−4.7%)
$25,300 + $125,500
$150,800
2017
$3,119 (+0.9%)
$25,300 + $125,500
$150,800
2016
$3,092 (+7.6%)
$25,300 + $125,500
$150,800
2015
$2,874 (+0.9%)
$25,300 + $125,500
$150,800
2014
$2,848
$25,300 + $125,500
$150,800
Tax history for 36523 Pulpit Rock Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2026
$2,959
$25,300 + $125,500
$150,800
2025
$2,959 (+6.3%)
$25,300 + $125,500
$150,800
2024
$2,783 (+1.9%)
$25,300 + $125,500
$150,800
2023
$2,730 (+0.9%)
$25,300 + $125,500
$150,800
2022
$2,705 (−6.5%)
$25,300 + $125,500
$150,800
2021
$2,894 (−1.3%)
$25,300 + $125,500
$150,800
2020
$2,932 (+1.4%)
$25,300 + $125,500
$150,800
2019
$2,893 (−2.7%)
$25,300 + $125,500
$150,800
2018
$2,972 (−4.7%)
$25,300 + $125,500
$150,800
2017
$3,119 (+0.9%)
$25,300 + $125,500
$150,800
2016
$3,092 (+7.6%)
$25,300 + $125,500
$150,800
2015
$2,874 (+0.9%)
$25,300 + $125,500
$150,800
2014
$2,848
$25,300 + $125,500
$150,800
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.