Welcome to 35 W O'Reilly, a beautifully maintained 1871 Victorian with many upgrades, perfectly situated on a rare double lot in Midtown Kingston. With over 2,400 square feet of living space including 4 beds and two full baths, a partially finished basement, original hardwood floors, picture moldings throughout, and abundant natural light in each room, this home offers the ideal blend of elegance and warmth. The inviting front and back porches are perfect for morning coffee, reading, or entertaining, and the expansive yard is one of the largest in the neighborhood, ideal for gardening and recreation. A large driveway provides off-street parking for 8+ vehicles. Step inside the grand entryway, complete with 10 foot ceilings that extend throughout the home. The generous floor plan flows gracefully from one space to the next. The double parlor (with original pocket doors) is ideal for both entertaining and relaxing. The formal dining room offers the perfect setting for hosting gatherings, and a large eat-in kitchen features ample counter space and a walk-in pantry. A convenient extra room on the first floor is perfect for a home office or studio. Wide plank flooring leads you to four generously sized bedrooms upstairs and two full baths, one on each level, this home easily accommodates both family life and guests. You'll find many closets throughout the home, and an extra large storage room located on the back side of the house through an outer door. Downstairs, a full, partially finished basement offers endless potential, featuring 8 ft. high ceilings, large windows, and lots of natural light, rare for a lower level! Currently housing a music studio and a large laundry/storage room, the space also features two separate exterior entrances, making it a strong candidate for conversion to an apartment or guest suite. All of this is centrally located in the heart of Kingston's vibrant midtown arts and culture scene. Enjoy easy access to acclaimed restaurants, art galleries, the YMCA, shopping, live music venues, and much more. You're also just about a mile from both the historic Uptown Stockade District and the scenic Downtown Waterfront, offering the best of all worlds. Updates include new roof and gutters (2019), boiler (2019), outdoor fencing (2020), washer and dryer (2023), 2nd floor full bathroom renovation (2022), front porch steps and railing (2024), hardwood floor refinishing (2025), basement renovation w/ hardwood floors (2024) and much more (see attached doc for full list of upgrades). Come see this gem and make this house your home. Welcome to 35 W O'Reilly, a beautifully maintained 1871 Victorian with many upgrades, perfectly situated on a rare double lot in Midtown Kingston. With over 2,400 square feet of living space plus a partially finished basement, original hardwood floors and picture moldings throughout, and abundant natural light in each room, this home offers the ideal blend of elegance and warmth. The inviting front and back porches are perfect for morning coffee, reading, or entertaining, and the expansive yard is one of the largest in the neighborhood, ideal for gardening and recreation. A large driveway provides off-street parking for 6+ vehicles. Step inside the grand entryway, complete with 9 foot ceilings that extend throughout the home. The generous floor plan flows gracefully from one space to the next. The double parlor (with original pocket doors) is ideal for both entertaining and relaxing. The formal dining room offers the perfect setting for hosting gatherings, and a large eat-in kitchen features ample counter space and a walk-in pantry. A convenient extra room on the first floor is perfect for a home office or studio. With four generously sized bedrooms upstairs and two full baths, one on each level, this home easily accommodates both family life and guests. Downstairs, a full, partially finished basement offers endless potential. Currently housing a music studio and a large laundry/storage room, the space also features two separate exterior entrances, making it a strong candidate for conversion to an apartment or guest suite. All of this is centrally located in the heart of Kingston's vibrant midtown arts and culture scene. Enjoy easy access to acclaimed restaurants, art galleries, the YMCA, shopping, live music venues, and much more. You're also just about a mile from both the historic Uptown Stockade District and the scenic Downtown Waterfront, offering the best of all worlds. Updates include new roof and gutters (2019), boiler (2019), outdoor fencing (2020), washer and dryer (2023), 2nd floor full bathroom renovation (2022), front porch steps and railing (2024), hardwood floor refinishing (2025), basement renovation w/ hardwood floors (2024) and much more (see attached doc for full list of upgrades). Come see this gem and make this house your home.
Single-familyProperty Type
1871Year Built
10,018 sq ftLot Size
$245Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
8 spacesParking
Listing by Lara Hope Levine• Compass Greater NY, LLC
Don’t let this incredible Victorian beauty located in popular Midtown Kingston pass you by. Boasting many original details including picture moldings and ornate radiators, this home offers a "double parlor" separated by pocket doors, plentiful library shelving and large bay windows. 9 Foot ceilings finish off the dramatic rooms. A very spacious eat in kitchen and a great walk in pantry with lots of storage are a home cooks dream. The house is built on a double lot, a rarity in midtown Kingston and offers a large backyard. The sizeable bedrooms all have plenty of closet space. The full basement under the original section of the house has two outside entrances that could easily pave the way to a mother-in-law type set up. Additional bonuses include original hard wood floors found underneath carpets and an oversized claw foot tub for long soaks. This gorgeous home is conveniently located very close to YMCA, Kingston High School, SUNY Ulster and local Hospitals. Great little cafes and restaurants can be found along nearby Broadway, all within walking distance.
HVCRMLS #20182013
May 25, 2018
Listed
$224,900
$74/sq ft
Public Records
Jun 15, 2004
Sold
$70,000
$23/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$12,984 (+11.0%)
$27,000 + $182,000
$209,000
2024
$11,693 (+5.6%)
$27,000 + $182,000
$209,000
2023
$11,074 (+2.8%)
$27,000 + $182,000
$209,000
2022
$10,772 (+0.2%)
$27,000 + $182,000
$209,000
2021
$10,751 (+46.1%)
$27,000 + $182,000
$209,000
2020
$7,357 (+3.0%)
$27,000 + $182,000
$209,000
2019
$7,146 (−1.8%)
$27,000 + $182,000
$209,000
2018
$7,275 (−1.6%)
$27,000 + $182,000
$209,000
2017
$7,394 (+0.4%)
$26,000 + $175,000
$201,000
2016
$7,368 (+38.0%)
$26,000 + $175,000
$201,000
2015
$5,340 (−2.6%)
$26,000 + $175,000
$201,000
2014
$5,483
$26,000 + $175,000
$201,000
Tax history for 35 W O'reilly St
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$12,984 (+11.0%)
$27,000 + $182,000
$209,000
2024
$11,693 (+5.6%)
$27,000 + $182,000
$209,000
2023
$11,074 (+2.8%)
$27,000 + $182,000
$209,000
2022
$10,772 (+0.2%)
$27,000 + $182,000
$209,000
2021
$10,751 (+46.1%)
$27,000 + $182,000
$209,000
2020
$7,357 (+3.0%)
$27,000 + $182,000
$209,000
2019
$7,146 (−1.8%)
$27,000 + $182,000
$209,000
2018
$7,275 (−1.6%)
$27,000 + $182,000
$209,000
2017
$7,394 (+0.4%)
$26,000 + $175,000
$201,000
2016
$7,368 (+38.0%)
$26,000 + $175,000
$201,000
2015
$5,340 (−2.6%)
$26,000 + $175,000
$201,000
2014
$5,483
$26,000 + $175,000
$201,000
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.
Public record
Public record
Zoning
Beds
4
Baths
2
Stories
2
Lot width
100 ft.
Lot depth
100 ft.
Lot size
10,000 Sq. Ft.
Year renovated
—
Sq. Ft.
2,400
Year built
1871
Style
Single Family Residential
County
Ulster County
APN
510800A05602600100450000000
Parking Spaces
—
Basement
—
Accessible
—
HOA Dues
—
Garage
—
Features
—
Last updated by owner on Jul 31, 2026.
T4N
Neighborhood District
To provide a variety of housing choices, in small- to medium-footprint, medium- to high-density building types, which reinforce the walkable nature of the neighborhood, support neighborhood-serving retail and service uses adjacent to this zone, and support public transportation alternatives. An open subzone provides the same building form but allows for a more diverse mix of uses.