Public Remarks: Beautifully updated 5-bedroom, 3-bath home on 5 acres offering 2,550 sq ft of comfortable living space. Remodeled between 2019-2026, this property features two wood-burning stoves, a new heat pump, and a tankless water heater for efficient year-round comfort. Major improvements include new windows in 2019, blown-in attic insulation in 2021, a new roof in 2023, a new 200-amp electrical panel, and a water softener installed in 2023. The land offers privacy and endless possibilities with two barns. One barn includes three stalls and a tack room with electric and water in place, while the second barn is a pole barn and is well-suited for easy addition of electric and water. A perfect blend of country living and modern upgrades. See feature sheet for full details.
Single-familyProperty Type
1972Year Built
5 acresLot Size
$266Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
2 car garageParking
Listed by Lisa Yates• Comey & Shepherd
•513-926-6975 (agent)
•ListWithLisa513@gmail.com (agent)
•513-777-2333 (broker)
•ayoung@comey.com (broker)
Bought with Tyler Morton• RE/MAX Victory + Affiliates
Beautifully updated 5-bedroom, 3-bath home on 5 acres offering 2,550 sq ft of comfortable living space. Remodeled between 2019-2026, this property features two wood-burning stoves, a new heat pump, and a tankless water heater for efficient year-round comfort. Major improvements include new windows in 2019, blown-in attic insulation in 2021, a new roof in 2023, a new 200-amp electrical panel, and a water softener installed in 2023. The land offers privacy and endless possibilities with two barns. One barn includes three stalls and a tack room with electric and water in place, while the second barn is a pole barn and is well-suited for easy addition of electric and water. A perfect blend of country living and modern upgrades. See feature sheet for full details.
Cincy MLS #1866492
Feb 27, 2026
Sold
$545,000
$238/sq ft
Jan 21, 2026
Contingent
—
Jan 19, 2026
Listed
$495,000
$216/sq ft
Dayton MLS #797505
Sep 30, 2019
Sold
$223,000
$97/sq ft
Sep 30, 2019
Sold
$223,000
$97/sq ft
Aug 11, 2019
Pending
—
Aug 1, 2019
Listed
$250,000
$109/sq ft
+45
This versatile property is a hobby-farm dream! A roomy bi-level home sits back on a large, open front yard. Apple trees blossom and blueberry and grape vines fill the back yard, while an open acre leads back to yet another wooded acre. The back two acres are both fenced in. The home has partial hard wood floors, a walk in closet in the main bedroom, a charming wrought iron indoor staircase railing, and (you'll never guess) an adorable laundry shoot! The partially underground lower-level stays cool all summer long, and warm all winter with a cozy wood-burning stove, while the convenience of a whole house fan pulls that comfortable temperature through out the home. Through the kitchen is a spacious screened in back porch to continue the flow of natural air. This AS IS property has the potential to be a loving, caring and thriving home, and is longing to be engaged again!
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$4,661 (+4.8%)
$53,340 + $64,720
$118,060
2024
$4,447 (+147.1%)
$53,340 + $64,720
$118,060
2023
$1,799 (−50.0%)
$33,579 + $57,442
$91,021
2022
$3,599 (+6.3%)
$33,579 + $57,442
$91,021
2021
$3,386 (+9.4%)
$33,579 + $57,442
$91,021
2020
$3,094 (+7.4%)
$27,300 + $46,701
$74,001
2019
$2,880
$27,300 + $46,701
$74,001
2018
$2,881 (+2.5%)
$27,300 + $46,701
$74,001
2017
$2,811 (−3.9%)
$23,720 + $42,382
$66,102
2016
$2,925 (+4.6%)
$23,720 + $42,382
$66,102
2014
$2,795
$22,677 + $37,842
$60,519
2013
$2,794
$22,677 + $37,842
$60,519
Tax history for 4957 Utica Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$4,661 (+4.8%)
$53,340 + $64,720
$118,060
2024
$4,447 (+147.1%)
$53,340 + $64,720
$118,060
2023
$1,799 (−50.0%)
$33,579 + $57,442
$91,021
2022
$3,599 (+6.3%)
$33,579 + $57,442
$91,021
2021
$3,386 (+9.4%)
$33,579 + $57,442
$91,021
2020
$3,094 (+7.4%)
$27,300 + $46,701
$74,001
2019
$2,880
$27,300 + $46,701
$74,001
2018
$2,881 (+2.5%)
$27,300 + $46,701
$74,001
2017
$2,811 (−3.9%)
$23,720 + $42,382
$66,102
2016
$2,925 (+4.6%)
$23,720 + $42,382
$66,102
2014
$2,795
$22,677 + $37,842
$60,519
2013
$2,794
$22,677 + $37,842
$60,519
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.