Beyond the stone pillars and down a tree-lined lane lies the hidden beauty of Arnolda. Founded as a hunting and fishing colony by the Arnold family, this secluded enclave has five association docks on Ninigret Pond, four of which have four slips each, and a private community dock on East Beach for the residents of Arnolda to enjoy. Tucked away within this setting, a unique and inviting post and beam home awaits. Facing south, with views of Ninigret Pond and the Atlantic beyond, this three level home offers 2,738 square feet of living area in perfect harmony with its natural setting. High ceilings, wide pine floors, a large fireplace, and expansive decks combine to create the perfect blend of coastal and cozy. Enjoy the association tennis/pickleball court, or boat over to the association dock adjacent to Charlestown Breachway it's the perfect place to tie up and enjoy the beach, or you can venture out to Block Island, Montauk, and beyond. On your return, rinse off the sand and salt in the outdoor shower, and relax on any one of the multi-level decks. With four bedrooms, a den, family room, and open loft space, there are plenty of places to entertain, relax, and nap after a sunny day at the beach. Arnolda also enjoys close proximity to local recreation such as Ninigret Park, where there are biking and walking trails, disc golf, a dog park, senior center, Frosty Drew observatory, and annual events such as the Seafood Festival and Rhythm and Roots.
Single-familyProperty Type
1985Year Built
1.19 acresLot Size
$681Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
1 car garageParking
Listed by Susan Mitchell• Mott & Chace Sotheby's Intl.
Listed by Charlotte Fiola• Mott & Chace Sotheby's Intl.
Bought with Sarah Huard• Mott & Chace Sotheby's Intl.
LOFTY 4BR/3BA CONTEMPORARY IN ARNOLDA COLONY POST & BEAM CONSTRUCTION LENDS A STURDY CHARACTER. LR/FP AND EXTRAORDINARY PRIVACY BORDERING NINIGRET PARK. PRIVATE BARRIER BEACH AND TENNIS PRIVILEGES.
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$11,303 (+2.6%)
$1,198,100 + $707,900
$1,906,000
2024
$11,017 (+0.7%)
$1,198,100 + $707,900
$1,906,000
2023
$10,940 (+77.5%)
$1,198,100 + $707,900
$1,906,000
2022
$6,164 (−0.1%)
$458,000 + $296,500
$754,500
2021
$6,172 (−0.6%)
$458,000 + $296,500
$754,500
2020
$6,210 (−4.3%)
$458,000 + $296,500
$754,500
2019
$6,491 (−4.3%)
$458,000 + $245,300
$703,300
2018
$6,780 (+0.5%)
$458,000 + $245,300
$703,300
2017
$6,745 (+4.5%)
$458,000 + $245,300
$703,300
2016
$6,454 (+1.0%)
$394,500 + $237,600
$632,100
2015
$6,391 (+2.1%)
$394,500 + $237,600
$632,100
2014
$6,258 (+1.7%)
$394,500 + $237,600
$632,100
2013
$6,156 (+1.7%)
$415,100 + $235,600
$650,700
2012
$6,052
$415,100 + $235,600
$650,700
Tax history for 79 Hunters Harbor Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$11,303 (+2.6%)
$1,198,100 + $707,900
$1,906,000
2024
$11,017 (+0.7%)
$1,198,100 + $707,900
$1,906,000
2023
$10,940 (+77.5%)
$1,198,100 + $707,900
$1,906,000
2022
$6,164 (−0.1%)
$458,000 + $296,500
$754,500
2021
$6,172 (−0.6%)
$458,000 + $296,500
$754,500
2020
$6,210 (−4.3%)
$458,000 + $296,500
$754,500
2019
$6,491 (−4.3%)
$458,000 + $245,300
$703,300
2018
$6,780 (+0.5%)
$458,000 + $245,300
$703,300
2017
$6,745 (+4.5%)
$458,000 + $245,300
$703,300
2016
$6,454 (+1.0%)
$394,500 + $237,600
$632,100
2015
$6,391 (+2.1%)
$394,500 + $237,600
$632,100
2014
$6,258 (+1.7%)
$394,500 + $237,600
$632,100
2013
$6,156 (+1.7%)
$415,100 + $235,600
$650,700
2012
$6,052
$415,100 + $235,600
$650,700
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.