Recently Sold Homes in Shelter Island, NY

Recently Sold Home in Shelter Island, NY:

Welcome to Pheasant Run in Greenport! MINT single level condo features a primary bedroom ensuite plus additional guest bedroom and full bath, eat-in-kitchen, full basement, and glass sliders to your own private deck. Enjoy carefree resort style living with access to the community inground pool and clubhouse. No age restriction, and minutes to vibrant downtown Greenport, beaches, vineyards and more!

Recently Sold Home in Shelter Island, NY:

Fully remodeled condo in the sought-after Cleves Point Club & Marina community of East Marion. Thoughtfully designed to maximize flow and highlight the stunning water views, this home features stylish, up-to-date renovations throughout. Primary ensuite bedroom with waterside deck and ample closet space. There is a loft for an additional bedroom and bath if needed. Home also includes a full basement and 2 washers and 2 dryers (upstairs and downstairs). Living room with sliders to back deck overlooking the water and marina. Other features include, full wet bar with a wine fridge, separate sink and, an ice maker. Not a single detail was missed while renovating the home. The community off

Recently Sold Home in Shelter Island, NY:

The quintessential East Marion beach cottage! This newly painted and carpeted light and airy 2br, 1 ba home boasts a living area with custom built ins. Laundry and a separate workshop is located just off of the kitchen. The large attic would be perfect as a finished bonus room. Enjoy bucolic farm views from the back yard or enjoy the Peconic Bay beach with views of Shelter Island and the famous 'Bug Light' lighthouse just . 2 mile at the end of the road. * Low Taxes! *

Recently Sold Home in Shelter Island, NY:

Live your best life in this spectacular 5 bedroom bayfront home. Breathtaking panoramic water views from Shelter Island throughout Greenport Harbor to Pipes Cove, you will be able to sit on your private beach and watch all the activity of the Peconic Bay. This beachfront home offers a first floor bedroom en-suite, enclosed sunporch, open floor plan across the living room with wood burning fireplace, dining area into the kitchen. The second floor offers 4 large bedrooms and a full bathroom. There are hardwood floors, central air conditioning, laundry on both floors, partial full height basement, and a beautiful waterside composite deck to enjoy the most amazing water view!

Recently Sold Home in Shelter Island, NY:

Charming 3-Bedroom Farmhouse in Summit Estates, East Marion! Welcome to this beautifully updated 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath farmhouse located in the sought-after Summit Estates community on the North Fork. This exceptional home offers private beach access with a community dock for daily mooring—perfect for boating enthusiasts and beach lovers alike. Nestled on a picturesque lot, the home features a classic wraparound porch ideal for relaxing and entertaining outdoors. Inside, you'll find hardwood floors throughout, an updated kitchen with modern finishes, and a spacious great room highlighted by soaring double-height ceilings and a cozy gas fireplace. The main level includes two generously

Recently Sold Home in Shelter Island, NY:

End unit- first floor 2 Bedroom 2 bathroom condo with a full basement and garage at Cleaves Point Condominium complex. Cleaves Point encompasses 14 acres of direct bay front land with manicured grounds, garden area, private sandy beach, marina, pool, clubhouse, gym, tennis, pickleball and basketball courts. Pay extra to dock a boat in a private slip on site. One of only four units like it in the entire complex, 5G1 has all the advantages of being a ground floor corner unit with two large bedrooms with closets, 2 full baths, wood burning fireplace, full high and dry basement and a full garage with a parking spot in front of it. Large Living Room with sliding doors to the deck with a bay wate