Fillmore, NY homes for sale & real estate

Fillmore, NY Homes for Sale

Discover the perfect fully furnished lakeside retreat with this beautifully updated 2-bedroom, 1-bath ranch-style home offering dock access to scenic Rushford Lake, NY. Situated on a generous 0.85-acre lot, this charming property combines modern comfort with the natural beauty of one of Western New York’s most sought-after lake destinations. Step inside to an open-concept living space that seamlessly connects the kitchen and living areas—ideal for entertaining or relaxing after a day on the water. The updated kitchen features contemporary cabinetry, sleek countertops, and modern appliances, while the spacious living area boasts plenty of natural light and cozy charm. Both bedroo

Fillmore, NY Homes for Sale

Large 2-story farmhouse situated on 21.2 acres with a pond, 36 x 60 pole building with electric, 20 x 36 barn or hay storage and a machinery storage building. The kitchen, sitting room, large first floor laundry and a large entrance area was all newly built, from the foundation up, in 2023. This newer section needs some finishing touches to make it complete and has ceramic tile flooring, cathedral ceilings, electric fireplace, super-sized bar/sink area and many cabinets for storage. The original part of the home has 4 bedrooms and one bath, formal dining room with stamped tin ceilings still in place, office room and a good sized living room. One room off the dining area is gutted for a poss

Fillmore, NY Homes for Sale

Prime Waterfront, Waterview, Lake, and Cottage! Simply said, life is better at Rushford Lake! Welcome to your fully restored & 100% move-in-ready original 1938 Sanford Hubbard cottage.  Each Hubbard cottage is unique and a part of the Arts and Crafts/Roycroft Movement.  Your cottage has been meticulously updated to maintain the original elements of a Hubbard Cottage while providing modern amenities and comfort.  The cottage exudes a relaxed feeling through the warmth of natural wood and exposed beams! Hubbard often used Hemlock or Pine while building and designed each fireplace using hand-picked stones with a signature butterfly design to note some of the distinguishing

Fillmore, NY Homes for Sale

Welcome to this stunning Amish-built homestead, a rare opportunity to enjoy quality craftsmanship, serene country living, and wide-open views in every direction. This beautifully maintained 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home offers 2,200 square feet of finished living space (Tax record sqft incorrect doesnt include additions measured by agent) a full walk-out basement that’s ready to be finished. The basement features a freshly epoxied floor, adding a clean and durable foundation for whatever you envision next. The home boasts a newly installed standing seam steel roof, aluminum siding, and maintenance-free vinyl windows, along with solid oak cabinetry in both the kitchen & baths. The m

Fillmore, NY Homes for Sale

This Beautiful and well maintained 3 bedroom 2 full bath ranch home sits on almost 4 acres with 1/2 of the property being wooded. Interior features an open floor plan with cathedral ceilings and new interior paint throughout. The eat in kitchen has stainless steel appliances, substantial cabinet storage, a breakfast bar and a large pantry. The master bedroom has a large ensuite bathroom. First floor laundry is included along with an attached garage with plenty of shelving for storage and an emergency backup generator hookup. Exterior updates include a paved driveway with new lighting and in the large and beautiful back yard a new architectural deck with pentagonal pergola. A back entrance w

Fillmore, NY Homes for Sale

Looking for that perfect little Get-A-Way? Well look no more this SEASONAL 2-bedroom 1-bath cabin has everything you'll need to start making those summer, family vacation memories. The home features cathedral ceiling spiral staircase knotty pine interior, electric baseboard heat, electric fireplace, laminate and ceramic title flooring. The kids will love to sleep in the upper loft. If the nights get hot, you can sleep in the enclosed front porch with the windows opened for a cooling breeze. Just minutes away is a neighborhood semi-private beach on Lakeshore Drive. Little ones can play in the sand and swim in shallow water. You can launch your boat at the public launch on Balcom Beach Road.