Horse Heaven! Situated in the middle of Hamilton's trail system - moments to Appleton Farm, Bradley Palmer, and Myopia. Raised ranch offers flexible floorplan, potential in-law on lower level. Some updating needed. 2+ stall barn and paddock.
Single-familyProperty Type
1974Year Built
2.1 acresLot Size
$495Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
8 spacesParking
Listed by Kristal Pooler• RE/MAX Advantage Real Estate
Bought with Blaze Johnson• RE/MAX Advantage Real Estate
This is a Raised ranch style home on 2.1 acres with a barn with horse stalls and fenced pasture. This is a horse property which is situated near riding trails. The house is in good condition but the kitchen could use updating.
8 years ago• May not reflect the current state of the home
Joe Petrucci
Redfin Associate agent
Sale history for 251 Cutler Rd
Date
Event
Price
MLSPIN #73493839
Apr 23, 2026
Rental Removed
$4,600
$2/sq ft
Apr 1, 2026
Listed for Rent
$4,600
$2/sq ft
MLS PIN #70308554
May 31, 2006
Sold
$540,000
$268/sq ft
Apr 25, 2006
Listing Removed
—
Jan 2, 2006
Listed
$579,000
$287/sq ft
Public Records
Oct 9, 1992
Sold
$240,000
$119/sq ft
Public Records
Aug 8, 1990
Sold
$55,000
$27/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2023
$11,806 (−1.9%)
$417,200 + $305,300
$722,500
2022
$12,030 (+16.3%)
$380,900 + $291,900
$672,800
2021
$10,341 (+11.5%)
$380,900 + $209,700
$590,600
2020
$9,273 (+9.6%)
$380,900 + $165,200
$546,100
2019
$8,464 (+7.9%)
$370,000 + $143,600
$513,600
2018
$7,841 (−1.2%)
$349,100 + $134,300
$483,400
2017
$7,938 (−1.7%)
$341,700 + $130,500
$472,200
2016
$8,073 (+4.9%)
$339,100 + $128,900
$468,000
2015
$7,696 (+2.7%)
$324,300 + $126,000
$450,300
2014
$7,491 (+1.4%)
$327,400 + $103,100
$430,500
2013
$7,390 (−2.1%)
$327,400 + $103,000
$430,400
2012
$7,545 (−1.9%)
$327,400 + $108,200
$435,600
2011
$7,693 (+0.6%)
$341,700 + $105,800
$447,500
2010
$7,648 (−2.5%)
$360,400 + $109,100
$469,500
2009
$7,848
$410,100 + $105,200
$515,300
Tax history for 251 Cutler Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2023
$11,806 (−1.9%)
$417,200 + $305,300
$722,500
2022
$12,030 (+16.3%)
$380,900 + $291,900
$672,800
2021
$10,341 (+11.5%)
$380,900 + $209,700
$590,600
2020
$9,273 (+9.6%)
$380,900 + $165,200
$546,100
2019
$8,464 (+7.9%)
$370,000 + $143,600
$513,600
2018
$7,841 (−1.2%)
$349,100 + $134,300
$483,400
2017
$7,938 (−1.7%)
$341,700 + $130,500
$472,200
2016
$8,073 (+4.9%)
$339,100 + $128,900
$468,000
2015
$7,696 (+2.7%)
$324,300 + $126,000
$450,300
2014
$7,491 (+1.4%)
$327,400 + $103,100
$430,500
2013
$7,390 (−2.1%)
$327,400 + $103,000
$430,400
2012
$7,545 (−1.9%)
$327,400 + $108,200
$435,600
2011
$7,693 (+0.6%)
$341,700 + $105,800
$447,500
2010
$7,648 (−2.5%)
$360,400 + $109,100
$469,500
2009
$7,848
$410,100 + $105,200
$515,300
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.