This young, very well maintained colonial is set privately on 4.5 acres. Beautiful grassy yard with sitting area and fire pit overlooking a ravine & adjacent forested acreage perfect for all kinds of outdoor enjoyment. Immaculate, traditional center hall colonial featuring a formal living & dining room w/ hardwood floors, an office & full bath. Lovely kitchen w/ a pantry and sliders out to a deck overlooking the back yard and woods. Upstairs are three bedrooms and a very nice full bath. In the winter there is a peek a boo view of the lake! A full, dry basement w/ walk out ability perfect for all your hobbies. Ease and confidence w/ municipal water & a well w/ great recovery so you can water your flowers, lawn & wash your car. Located just far enough from town that you escape to a peaceful, private setting yet just minutes from Myers Town Park with its boat launch and the Lansing Schools, Ithaca, Shops at Ithaca Mall & Cornell University are within approx 20 minute drive. Very nice home
This young, very well maintained colonial is set privately on 4.5 acres. Beautiful grassy yard with sitting area and fire pit overlooking a ravine & adjacent forested acreage perfect for all kinds of outdoor enjoyment. Immaculate, traditional center hall colonial featuring a formal living & dining room w/ hardwood floors, an office & full bath. Lovely kitchen w/ a pantry and sliders out to a deck overlooking the back yard and woods. Upstairs are three bedrooms and a very nice full bath. In the winter there is a peek a boo view of the lake! A full, dry basement w/ walk out ability perfect for all your hobbies. Ease and confidence w/ municipal water & a well w/ great recovery so you can water your flowers, lawn & wash your car. Located just far enough from town that you escape to a peaceful, private setting yet just minutes from Myers Town Park with its boat launch and the Lansing Schools, Ithaca, Shops at Ithaca Mall & Cornell University are within approx 20 minute drive. Very nice home
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2026
$10,212
$43,800 + $331,200
$375,000
2025
$10,212 (+4.2%)
$43,800 + $331,200
$375,000
2024
$9,798 (+9.2%)
$43,800 + $331,200
$375,000
2023
$8,972 (−0.5%)
$43,800 + $266,200
$310,000
2022
$9,015 (+16.1%)
$43,800 + $251,200
$295,000
2021
$7,766 (+16.9%)
$43,800 + $201,200
$245,000
2020
$6,643 (+0.4%)
$43,800 + $183,200
$227,000
2019
$6,618 (+0.2%)
$43,800 + $183,200
$227,000
2018
$6,605 (−0.3%)
$43,800 + $183,200
$227,000
2017
$6,622 (+0.5%)
$43,800 + $183,200
$227,000
2016
$6,587 (+176.4%)
$33,800 + $193,200
$227,000
2015
$2,383 (−50.3%)
$33,800 + $193,200
$227,000
2014
$4,797
$33,800 + $176,200
$210,000
Tax history for 251 Algerine Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2026
$10,212
$43,800 + $331,200
$375,000
2025
$10,212 (+4.2%)
$43,800 + $331,200
$375,000
2024
$9,798 (+9.2%)
$43,800 + $331,200
$375,000
2023
$8,972 (−0.5%)
$43,800 + $266,200
$310,000
2022
$9,015 (+16.1%)
$43,800 + $251,200
$295,000
2021
$7,766 (+16.9%)
$43,800 + $201,200
$245,000
2020
$6,643 (+0.4%)
$43,800 + $183,200
$227,000
2019
$6,618 (+0.2%)
$43,800 + $183,200
$227,000
2018
$6,605 (−0.3%)
$43,800 + $183,200
$227,000
2017
$6,622 (+0.5%)
$43,800 + $183,200
$227,000
2016
$6,587 (+176.4%)
$33,800 + $193,200
$227,000
2015
$2,383 (−50.3%)
$33,800 + $193,200
$227,000
2014
$4,797
$33,800 + $176,200
$210,000
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.
Public record
Public record
Zoning
Beds
3
Baths
2
Stories
2
Lot width
—
Lot depth
—
Lot size
4.5 Acres
Year renovated
—
Sq. Ft.
1,496
Year built
2005
Style
Single Family Residential
County
Tompkins County
APN
503289A01500000010010110000
Parking Spaces
—
Basement
—
Accessible
—
HOA Dues
—
Garage
—
Features
—
Last updated by owner on Aug 10, 2026.
L1
Lakeshore District
The intent of the L1 District is to designate areas that are adjacent or have access to the shoreline of Cayuga Lake and are environmentally sensitive. Continued residential and limited nonresidential developments are appropriate uses for such areas. Regulations and development standards are aimed at minimizing environmental damage to natural resources, preventing erosion, and responding to potential problems related to steep slopes and inadequate water and sewer services.
Property details
Parking
Parking/Garage Information
Has Garage
Has Attached Garage
# of Garage Spaces: 2
Parking Features: Gravel, Garage Door Opener, Attached