Steps from Long Island Sound, this architecturally stunning home offers stylish living space, complete with enviable water views and access to an exclusive neighborhood boat club. This elegant residence features 5+ bedrooms, 3.5 bathrooms, and 4500+ square feet of living space and a private, beautifully-landscaped yard. Upon entering the home, you're greeted by a warm and inviting covered porch and soaring foyer ceilings. The first floor features a sun-drenched eat-in kitchen, spacious formal dining room with custom millwork and fireplace, ample living room with additional fireplace, and bright sun room, with a third fireplace. Ascending the three-story, open staircase brings you to the expansive second story, which includes the primary suite, with private library/sitting room and spa-like bathroom. An additional two bedrooms and full bath complete the second floor. The third floor adds two additional bedrooms, a full bathroom, and a large office with a private terrace. Additional Information: Amenities:Storage,
Single-familyProperty Type
1912Year Built
0.33 acresLot Size
$364Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
Listing by Nicole Capuano Ball• Compass Greater NY, LLC
Listing by Elizabeth Winkler• Compass Greater NY, LLC
Great opportunity to live in sought after Sutton Manor - a neighborhood & boater's delight! This 6 bdrm, 4.1 bth CH colonial offers old world charm w. wood detailing, wood floors, 4 fireplaces, 3 front porches + water views. Details & built-ins galore. Steps away from Sutton Manor Assoc's Boathouse, moorings & beach. Detached garage perfect for workshop/artist studio. Walk to RR - only 33 min. to NYC. Taxes do not reflect NYS STAR. Home is currently assessed at over $823K. Taxes can be grieved!
OneKey® MLS as Distributed by MLS Grid #H3204363
Apr 17, 2013
Sold
$710,000
$157/sq ft
Feb 9, 2012
Listed
$699,021
$154/sq ft
Great opportunity to live in sought after Sutton Manor - a neighborhood & boater's delight! This 6 bdrm, 4.1 bth CH colonial offers old world charm w. wood detailing, wood floors, 4 fireplaces, 3 front porches + water views. Details & built-ins galore. Steps away from Sutton Manor Assoc's Boathouse, moorings & beach. Detached garage perfect for workshop/artist studio. Walk to RR - only 33 min. to NYC. Taxes do not reflect NYS STAR. Home is currently assessed at over $823K. Taxes can be grieved! Additional Information: ParkingFeatures:1 Car Detached,
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2026
$27,050 (+34.4%)
$4,450 + $16,530
$20,980
2025
$20,121 (−17.8%)
$4,450 + $16,530
$20,980
2024
$24,486 (+4.1%)
$4,450 + $14,750
$19,200
2023
$23,522
$4,450 + $14,750
$19,200
2022
$23,502 (+0.4%)
$4,450 + $14,750
$19,200
2021
$23,413 (+20.7%)
$4,450 + $14,750
$19,200
2020
$19,397 (−7.0%)
$4,450 + $14,750
$19,200
2019
$20,867
$4,450 + $14,750
$19,200
2018
$4,450 + $14,750
$19,200
2017
$4,450 + $14,750
$19,200
2016
$4,450 + $14,750
$19,200
2014
$4,450 + $17,750
$22,200
2013
$4,450 + $17,750
$22,200
2012
$4,450 + $17,750
$22,200
2011
$4,450 + $17,750
$22,200
2010
$4,450 + $17,200
$21,650
2009
$4,450 + $17,200
$21,650
2008
$4,450 + $17,200
$21,650
Tax history for 125 Sutton Manor Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2026
$27,050 (+34.4%)
$4,450 + $16,530
$20,980
2025
$20,121 (−17.8%)
$4,450 + $16,530
$20,980
2024
$24,486 (+4.1%)
$4,450 + $14,750
$19,200
2023
$23,522
$4,450 + $14,750
$19,200
2022
$23,502 (+0.4%)
$4,450 + $14,750
$19,200
2021
$23,413 (+20.7%)
$4,450 + $14,750
$19,200
2020
$19,397 (−7.0%)
$4,450 + $14,750
$19,200
2019
$20,867
$4,450 + $14,750
$19,200
2018
$4,450 + $14,750
$19,200
2017
$4,450 + $14,750
$19,200
2016
$4,450 + $14,750
$19,200
2014
$4,450 + $17,750
$22,200
2013
$4,450 + $17,750
$22,200
2012
$4,450 + $17,750
$22,200
2011
$4,450 + $17,750
$22,200
2010
$4,450 + $17,200
$21,650
2009
$4,450 + $17,200
$21,650
2008
$4,450 + $17,200
$21,650
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.