Renting vs Buying in Orlando, FL: Which is Right for You?

by
Updated on March 15th, 2024

Reading Time: 7 minutes

With sparkling blue waters, lush lakefront parks, towering skyscrapers, famous theme parks, and endless sunny days, Orlando is a fabulous place to live in Florida. Whether you’re moving to or have lived in the area for some time, you may be wondering if now is the time to buy versus rent a home in Orlando. In addition to Orlando’s real estate market conditions, there are always pros and cons to renting and buying, making your decision a little more difficult.

If you’re considering buying a home in Orlando, you’ll see the current median sale price for a home is $370,000, as of June. According to Redfin’s recent study, the estimated median monthly mortgage cost is $2,966 while the average rent price in Orlando is $2,566. For many potential homebuyers, this means renting a home costs less than buying a home in today’s market. However, it’s important to keep in mind there are still plenty of reasons why buying a home right now may be the right choice for you. 

Ultimately, the decision between buying a house or renting an apartment in Orlando is personal and depends on several factors. Whether that’s your desire for flexibility or stability, your financial goals, or which one of the Orlando neighborhoods you want to live in, there is plenty to consider. We’ll help guide you along the way as you make the decision between renting vs buying in Orlando. That way, you can make the best decision for your goals.

home in orlando florida with palm trees

Advantages of buying a home in Orlando

Buying a property in Orlando can offer several compelling advantages over renting. Let’s dive into some of the main advantages of buying in the current market.

Building equity

Firstly, homeownership provides long-term stability and the opportunity to build equity. Instead of paying rent that provides no return on investment, homeowners can invest in their own property and potentially benefit from appreciation in the real estate market. 

Tax benefits

As a homeowner, there are a few potential tax benefits you may be eligible to receive. For example, mortgage interest and property tax payments may be tax-deductible, providing potential financial benefits. Speaking with a financial advisor or tax consultant can help you identify any possible tax benefits you may qualify for.

Freedom to design space

Owning a home also offers the freedom to personalize and modify the property to suit individual preferences without seeking permission from a landlord. 

Market conditions

Finally, as Orlando continues to experience growth and development, homeowners can potentially capitalize on the area’s thriving real estate market. By purchasing a property in Orlando, individuals can secure a long-term asset while enjoying the benefits and pride that come with homeownership.

Your future home is just a tap away

Explore homes with the Redfin app anytime, anywhere.
Disadvantages of buying a home in Orlando

High demand and competitive market

Orlando’s real estate market has experienced significant growth and demand in recent years, which can lead to increased competition among buyers. This high demand may result in bidding wars and inflated prices, making it more challenging to find affordable housing options. Additionally, limited inventory and a seller’s market can make it more difficult to find a property that meets your specific needs and budget. 

Property insurance costs

Florida, including Orlando, is at risk of natural disasters like hurricanes. As a result, the state often experiences higher property insurance costs compared to other regions. Homeowners in Orlando may need to pay higher insurance premiums to adequately protect their property against potential storm damage or other weather-related risks. These increased insurance expenses can add to the overall cost of homeownership in the area.

neighborhood in orlando with greenery and blue sky

Determining if you are ready to buy a house in Orlando

Deciding if buying a home in Orlando aligns with your goals can be a complicated question to answer. You’ll have to consider many factors such as your desired location, finances and budget, as well as the housing market conditions. Here are some of the main factors to consider:

1. Financial stability and affordability: Before beginning your homebuying journey, evaluate your financial situation and affordability. Consider factors such as mortgage interest rates, your credit score, and your ability to make a down payment. Lower interest rates can make homeownership more affordable, while higher rates could impact your purchasing power.

2. Long-term plans: Consider your long-term plans and how they align with buying a home in the greater Orlando area. If you plan to live in the area for a significant period, buying a home can be a good investment. However, if you’re uncertain about your future plans or have short-term goals, renting might be more suitable.

3. Housing market conditions: Consider the current state of the housing market in terms of supply and demand. If there is low inventory and high demand, it may indicate a seller’s market, which could lead to increased competition and potentially higher prices. On the other hand, if there is a higher inventory and less demand, it may be more favorable for buyers.

4. Housing preferences: Evaluate the type of property you’re looking for, such as single-family homes, condos, or townhouses, and assess their availability and affordability in the area. Consider factors like neighborhood amenities, school districts, and proximity to your workplace or desired locations.

5. Location: Orlando is a diverse metropolitan area with various neighborhoods and suburbs. Consider your preferred proximity to amenities, schools, workplaces, and entertainment options. Research the different neighborhoods to find the one that aligns with your lifestyle and preferences.

6. Employment opportunities: If you’re moving from out of the area, another factor to consider is employment. Orlando is known for its tourism industry, but it also has a diverse economy with opportunities in healthcare, technology, education, and more. Research the local job market to ensure there are opportunities in your field or industries of interest. 

7. Climate: Orlando experiences a subtropical climate with hot and humid summers and mild winters. Take into account your preferences for weather and seasonal changes when deciding to move to the area.

aerial view of a suburban orlando neighborhood_Getty

Is it competitive to buy a home in Orlando?

If you’re considering buying a home now, you can expect to encounter some competition in the real estate market. Here are a few factors that can contribute to the competition among buyers: 

Low housing inventory: One common factor driving competition is a shortage of available homes for sale in many areas. If there are fewer homes on the market, it means more buyers are vying for the same properties, which can increase competition. 

High demand: Strong demand from buyers, coupled with low interest rates, can create a competitive environment. Factors such as population growth, job opportunities, and popular neighborhoods can drive up demand for housing, leading to increased competition among buyers. 

Multiple offers: In a competitive market, it’s not uncommon for sellers to receive multiple offers on a property. This can lead to bidding wars, where buyers try to outbid each other to secure the home. In such situations, you may need to act quickly and offer competitive terms to increase your chances of success. 

Cash offers and pre-approved financing: Buyers who can make cash offers or have pre-approved financing may have an advantage over others. Cash offers are attractive to sellers as they eliminate the risk of financing falling through, while pre-approved buyers have already taken steps to secure financing, making their offers more reliable. 

Location and desirable features: Homes in highly sought-after locations or with desirable features like good school districts, proximity to amenities, or unique characteristics may attract significant competition. Buyers looking for properties with these qualities may face additional competition from others seeking similar homes. 

Real estate market conditions: Market conditions can vary regionally, and some areas may be more competitive than others. It’s important to research and understand the local market dynamics, as they can greatly impact the level of competition you may encounter. 

To navigate a competitive market, it’s essential to work with a knowledgeable real estate agent who can guide you through the process, help you make competitive offers, and identify suitable opportunities. Being prepared, flexible, and financially ready can also increase your chances of success in a competitive buying environment.

lake nona neighborhood in orlando florida

Advantages of renting a home in Orlando

If you’re contemplating renting a home or apartment in the Orlando area, there are a few advantages to consider: 

Flexibility

Renting provides greater flexibility and mobility compared to buying a house. If you’re unsure about your long-term plans or expect to move frequently, renting allows you to easily relocate without the burden of selling a property or dealing with the real estate market. This flexibility is particularly advantageous for individuals who prioritize mobility due to job changes, lifestyle preferences, or other personal circumstances. 

Lower upfront and ongoing costs

Renting typically involves lower upfront costs compared to buying a house. When you rent, you generally only need to provide a security deposit and possibly pay for any application or administrative fees. On the other hand, buying a house involves significant upfront expenses such as a downpayment, closing costs, home inspections, and potential repairs. Additionally, as a renter, you’re generally not responsible for major maintenance and repair costs, which can save you money and the hassle of dealing with unexpected expenses.

Disadvantages of renting a home in Orlando

Lack of long-term financial benefits

When you rent a house, you don’t build equity or gain potential long-term financial benefits like homeownership. Rent payments don’t contribute towards ownership or potential property appreciation. Instead, your money goes towards the landlord’s investment, providing no return on investment for yourself.

Limited control and restrictions

Renting a house often means you have less control over the property. You may face restrictions on making modifications or personalizing the space to suit your preferences. Additionally, your lease terms may subject you to rules and regulations set by the landlord or property management company. This lack of control can limit your ability to truly make the rental property feel like your own home.

Thinking about moving to the area?

Find the right loan for the home you love.

Renting vs buying in Orlando: A real estate agent’s final thoughts

Historically, the greater Orlando area has been a popular destination for homebuyers due to its warm climate, attractions, employment opportunities, and overall quality of life. As you make the decision between renting vs buying in Orlando, make sure to consider the market conditions, your financial situation, long-term plans, and housing preferences.

Remember, real estate markets can be dynamic and subject to change. It’s crucial to conduct thorough research, consult with local experts, and assess your personal circumstances before making any decisions. At the end of the day, whether you decide to rent an apartment or buy a home, the Orlando area is a fantastic place to call home.

If you are represented by an agent, this is not a solicitation of your business. This article is for informational purposes only, and is not a substitute for professional advice from a medical provider, licensed attorney, financial advisor, or tax professional. Consumers should independently verify any agency or service mentioned will meet their needs. Learn more about our Editorial Guidelines here.
Nancy Grabowski | Redfin Real Estate Agent

Nancy Grabowski | Redfin Real Estate Agent

Serving homebuyers and sellers in the Orlando area, Nancy Grabowski is a top real estate agent at Redfin with the latest market insights and local expertise. With years of experience as a real estate agent in the greater Orlando area, Nancy Grabowski possesses a wealth of knowledge and expertise in the local market.

Connect with Nancy

Find the right loan for the home you love

Find the right loan for the home you love

Homes for sale in

Orlando

Home Image
$337,000
3 beds, 2 baths, 1268 sq ft
818 Baltimore Dr, ORLANDO, FL
Home Image
$75,000
2 beds, 2 baths, 930 sq ft
2524 Woodgate Blvd #101, ORLANDO, FL
Home Image
$124,900
4 beds, 1 baths, 1050 sq ft
3935 Wells St, Orlando, FL
Home Image
$499,900
3 beds, 2 baths, 2001 sq ft
3307 Heathgate Ct, ORLANDO, FL
Home Image
$335,000
3 beds, 2 baths, 1932 sq ft
3346 W Washington St, ORLANDO, FL
Start your home search on Redfin
Scroll to Top