Character may be an overused word in real estate, but it’s a rare home that exhibits as much warm gravitas as Old Hankins Manor. From the moment you pull up the drive, past the private half acre pond and up to the wraparound rocking chair porch, you’re struck by a sense of timelessness and comfortable elegance. Tucked back from the quiet country road, this home has stood sentinel over the surrounding farmland for over 125 years. The formal front entrance welcomes you into a generous foyer with ornate staircase. Nestled behind this is a cozy media room, tucked away from the rest of the living space. The sitting room and den with stone double-sided fireplace welcome you into the primary entertaining space, then through to the spacious formal dining room, with the other face of the fireplace and wooden built-in shelving. The kitchen is highly functional while retaining an old country charm - think red checkered linens, aged porcelain sink, weathered wood and fresh baked cherry pies. Off this space is a convenient pantry with floor to ceiling cabinets and an additional sink. A full bathroom off the kitchen also houses a washer/dryer unit. At the second floor landing, you’ll find a lovely, sunny sitting room before heading down the hallway housing five bedrooms, each with a distinct character, allowing you to direct your guests to the ‘lilac room’ or the ‘red room’. There are two full bathrooms on this floor, one with a clawfoot tub, positioned under a dramatic stained glass window, and another with a tiled shower with charming old-style fixtures. The third floor houses a massive primary suite. The bedroom features a circus-tent-like peaked ceiling, working brick fireplace and large sitting area. A full en suite bath offers another clawfoot soaking tub and walk in tiled shower with skylight. A charming dressing room and large glass-encased office finish off this floor. Outside, a pathway off the back of the house leads past a stone patio with fire pit to the heated pool. The simple layout of the this area allows you to appreciate the natural privacy of open fields and mature trees. To the other side of the property, the clear freshwater pond offers opportunities for swimming, paddling, and peaceful contemplation. The front lawn is large and lightly sloping, making it inviting for lawn games for your family and friends. Almost unbelievably, this idyllic escape is also just a ten minute walk to all the charms and conveniences of Main Street, Callicoon.
Single-familyProperty Type
1900Year Built
5.19 acresLot Size
$331Price/Sq.Ft.
Listing by Megan Kinealy• Country House Realty Inc
Character may be an overused word in real estate, but it's a rare home that exhibits as much warm gravitas as Old Hankins Manor. From the moment you pull up the drive, past the private half acre pond and up to the wraparound rocking chair porch, you're struck by a sense of timelessness and comfortable elegance. Tucked back from the quiet country road, this home has stood sentinel over the surrounding farmland for over 100 years. The formal front entrance welcomes you into a generous foyer with ornate staircase. Nestled behind this is a cozy media room, tucked away from the rest of the living space. The sitting room and den with stone double-sided fireplace welcome you into the primary entertaining space, then through to the spacious formal dining room, with the other face of the fireplace and wooden built-in shelving. The kitchen is highly functional while retaining an old country charm - think red checkered linens, aged porcelain sink, weathered wood and fresh baked cherry pies. Off this space is a convenient pantry with floor to ceiling cabinets and an additional sink. A full bathroom off the kitchen also houses a washer/dryer unit. At the second floor landing, you'll find a lovely, sunny sitting room before heading down the hallway housing five bedrooms, each with a distinct character, allowing you to direct your guests to the 'lilac room' or the 'red room'. There are two full bathrooms on this floor, one with a clawfoot tub, positioned under a dramatic stained glass window, and another with a tiled shower with charming old-style fixtures. The third floor houses a massive primary suite. The bedroom features a circus-tent-like peaked ceiling, working brick fireplace and large sitting area. A full en suite bath offers another clawfoot soaking tub and walk in tiled shower with skylight. A charming dressing room and large glass-encased office finish off this floor. Outside, a pathway off the back of the house leads past a stone patio with fire pit to the heated pool. The simple layout of the this area allows you to appreciate the natural privacy of open fields and mature trees. To the other side of the property, the clear freshwater pond offers opportunities for swimming, paddling, and peaceful contemplation. The front lawn is large and lightly sloping, making it inviting for lawn games for your family and friends. Almost unbelievably, this idyllic escape is also just a ten minute walk to all the charms and conveniences of Main Street, Callicoon.
OneKey® MLS as Distributed by MLS Grid #898448
Oct 31, 2025
Listing Removed
—
Aug 11, 2025
Listed
$1,495,000
$366/sq ft
HVCRMLS #20253598
Aug 11, 2025
Listed
$1,495,000
$366/sq ft
HGMLS #504071
Jun 1, 2012
Sold
$398,842
$98/sq ft
Apr 18, 2012
Delisted
—
Mar 1, 2011
Listed
$399,000
$98/sq ft
HGMLS #4203430
May 31, 2012
Sold
$398,842
$98/sq ft
Mar 1, 2011
Listed
$399,000
$98/sq ft
Public Records
Oct 11, 2002
Sold
$600,000
$147/sq ft
Public Records
Apr 13, 2001
Sold
$400,000
$98/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$11,900 (−0.2%)
$51,600 + $289,100
$340,700
2024
$11,930 (+1.0%)
$51,600 + $289,100
$340,700
2023
$11,808 (−1.8%)
$51,600 + $289,100
$340,700
2022
$12,019 (+6.1%)
$51,600 + $289,100
$340,700
2021
$11,331 (+0.7%)
$51,600 + $289,100
$340,700
2020
$11,253 (+0.5%)
$51,600 + $289,100
$340,700
2019
$11,199 (+2.3%)
$51,600 + $289,100
$340,700
2018
$10,943 (+0.1%)
$51,600 + $289,100
$340,700
2017
$10,932 (+1.4%)
$51,600 + $289,100
$340,700
2016
$10,776 (−10.8%)
$51,600 + $289,100
$340,700
2015
$12,083 (−0.1%)
$51,600 + $289,100
$340,700
2014
$12,096
$26,850 + $220,254
$247,104
Public record
Beds
6
Baths
4
Stories
2.7
Lot width
—
Lot depth
—
Lot size
5.19 Acres
Year renovated
1985
Finished Sq. Ft.
4,080
Unfinished Sq. Ft.
—
Total Sq. Ft.
4,080
Year built
1900
Style
Single Family Residential
County
Sullivan County
APN
482600A010 00010092
Parking Spaces
—
Basement
—
Accessible
—
HOA Dues
—
Garage
—
Features
—
Last updated by owner on Jul 22, 2026.
Historical weather
Callicoon, NY • 12723
Average low and high temperatures (°F)
28
14
32
17
50
29
59
38
66
47
78
57
84
63
78
55
74
51
63
40
48
32
34
19
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
Sun exposure
94/ 100
Exceptional sunlight
Sunscore
This home receives average direct sun exposure in Callicoon. There appears to be minimal shading by surrounding buildings, terrain, and vegetation.
10.4 hrs
6.8 hrs
JuneDecember
Provided by Shadowmap
Redfin Estimate for 91 Old Hankins Rd
We cannot show automated home-value estimates for this home.
Nearby homes have recently sold between $385,000 and $1,250,000.
Nearby comparable homes
The Redfin Estimate uses 6 recent nearby sales, priced between $385K to $1.3M.