Discover a perfect blend of history and modern comfort in this stunning 5-bedroom, 2-bathroom Charming Historic Victorian style Farmhouse nestled on approximately 5 acres of picturesque countryside. The original "Hoyt Hagerdon" homestead, this beautiful home offers a truly classic charm with such details as transom windows, stained glass, glass doorknobs, a brass doorbell and beautiful woodwork. Step inside to a warm and inviting country kitchen, featuring gorgeous American chestnut floors, massive farmhouse sink, Elmira Victorian stove and French doors leading to the formal dining room which is simply beautiful with a bay window and open staircase landing. The enormous brick fireplace in the spacious living room provides a coziness rarely found in modern homes. The living room/parlor also features beautiful Turkish mosaic lights. There is plenty of space for gatherings of any size. Featuring 5 spacious bedrooms upstairs; the primary bedroom boasts vaulted ceilings with exposed beams and a private balcony, ideal for relaxing. The two bathrooms are updated with the upstairs bath featuring classic tiles, a stunning walk in shower and vaulted ceilings. Two large covered porches provide additional outdoor living space, perfect for enjoying the breathtaking views of the rolling landscape. Additional features include a concrete driveway and car port large enough for an RV! The additional attached workshop is perfect for any hobby or storage. One of the standout features of this property is the indoor Olympic-length lap pool! The room is heated with a wood stove, offering year-round fitness and recreation. The land itself is a nature lover’s dream, with mature fruit trees dotting the landscape, adding to the serene and private atmosphere. Whether a family home or a bed and breakfast or tea room this home has unbelievable potential. Sellers will consider selling home furnished down to linens and small items, as much of the contents were purchased specifically for this house. Located in the highly sought-after Falconer School District, Don’t miss this rare opportunity to own a piece of history in beautiful Ellington, NY!
Single-familyProperty Type
1890Year Built
5 acresLot Size
$161Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
1 spaceParking
Listing by AnnaMarie Bennett• ERA Team VP Real Estate
•716-413-0200 (broker)
•sales@vacationpro.com (broker)
Contact: 716-397-4382
Bought with Jeffrey Borysewicz• WNY Metro Roberts Realty
Claim this home to receive a free report every month with insights on the changing estimate.
Earn from this home
Refinance
$0
Est. cash available
Get cash now or lower your monthly rate
Rent
$2,067/mo
Redfin rental estimate
List your home for rent
Market trends in 14740, NY
Last updated September 2026
Sale-to-list price
100.7%
+0.7% MoM
Median sale price
$239K
$70 MoM
Avg. days on market
11d
63 days MoM
Recently sold homes
3
2 MoM
Provided by Redfin
Sale history for 1198 Hagerdon Hill Rd
Date
Event
Price
UNYREIS #R1595588
Aug 12, 2025
Sold
$255,000
$136/sq ft
May 1, 2025
Pending
—
Apr 10, 2025
Listed
$259,900
$138/sq ft
WNYREIS #B428921
May 1, 2014
Sold
$145,000
$77/sq ft
Nov 26, 2013
Listing Removed
—
May 4, 2013
Listed
$139,900
$74/sq ft
NEW PRICE! MOVE OUT TO THE COUNTRY AND ENJOY THIS VINTAGE BEAUTY! A WONDERFUL BLEND OF OLD AND NEW DECOR ACCENTUATES THIS 5 BEDROOM, 2 BATH VICTORIAN STYLE HOME ON 9+ ACRES. NATURAL WOODWORK AND FLOORING ADD TO THE CHARACTER OF THIS PERIOD HOME. WARM YOURSELF IN FRONT OF THE BRICK FIREPLACE. UPDATED MECHANICS AND NEWER WINDOWS. CONVENIENT FIRST FLOOR LAUNDRY, BATH AND MUDROOM WHICH CONNECT TO THE ENCLOSED FULL SIZE, HEATED IN-GROUND LAP POOL. STROLL THROUGH THE PERENIAL GARDENS, FRUIT TREES, BERRY BUSHES IN THE YARD. DON'T MISS OUT ON THIS BEAUTY! CALL TODAY FOR AN APPOINTMENT.
WNYREIS #B428928
Jul 23, 2013
Listing Removed
—
May 4, 2013
Listed
$174,900
$93/sq ft
WNYREIS #B405064
Oct 1, 2012
Listing Removed
—
Apr 2, 2012
Listed
$199,000
$106/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2026
$4,635
$45,200 + $130,800
$176,000
2025
$4,635 (−6.9%)
$45,200 + $130,800
$176,000
2024
$4,976 (+0.3%)
$43,300 + $132,700
$176,000
2023
$4,961 (−2.6%)
$33,900 + $132,100
$166,000
2022
$5,092 (+4.9%)
$29,300 + $124,400
$153,700
2021
$4,854 (+9.5%)
$23,900 + $115,800
$139,700
2020
$4,432 (+2.1%)
$23,900 + $115,800
$139,700
2019
$4,342 (+2.1%)
$18,900 + $101,100
$120,000
2018
$4,252 (−2.0%)
$18,900 + $101,100
$120,000
2017
$4,340 (+0.1%)
$18,900 + $101,100
$120,000
2016
$4,334 (+0.9%)
$18,900 + $101,100
$120,000
2015
$4,296 (−31.2%)
$18,900 + $101,100
$120,000
2014
$6,242
$18,900 + $101,100
$120,000
Tax history for 1198 Hagerdon Hill Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2026
$4,635
$45,200 + $130,800
$176,000
2025
$4,635 (−6.9%)
$45,200 + $130,800
$176,000
2024
$4,976 (+0.3%)
$43,300 + $132,700
$176,000
2023
$4,961 (−2.6%)
$33,900 + $132,100
$166,000
2022
$5,092 (+4.9%)
$29,300 + $124,400
$153,700
2021
$4,854 (+9.5%)
$23,900 + $115,800
$139,700
2020
$4,432 (+2.1%)
$23,900 + $115,800
$139,700
2019
$4,342 (+2.1%)
$18,900 + $101,100
$120,000
2018
$4,252 (−2.0%)
$18,900 + $101,100
$120,000
2017
$4,340 (+0.1%)
$18,900 + $101,100
$120,000
2016
$4,334 (+0.9%)
$18,900 + $101,100
$120,000
2015
$4,296 (−31.2%)
$18,900 + $101,100
$120,000
2014
$6,242
$18,900 + $101,100
$120,000
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.