Step into the charm and character of this one-of-a-kind historic home built in 1754, nestled atop a hill with panoramic views. With 4 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, breathtaking scenic mountain views, inground swimming pool, hot tub, and large barn sitting on over 5 acres of land, this property invites you to embrace the serenity of Catskills living. Whether you're seeking a weekend retreat or a full-time residence, this home has it all. You'll first be greeted by a proper entryway and gallery hallway, which leads to a kitchen designed for effortless entertaining. The kitchen flows seamlessly into the formal dining room, where a modern chandelier casts a warm glow over intimate dinners and festive gatherings alike. The inviting living room has a natural stone fireplace creates a cozy ambiance on chilly evenings. Built-in bookshelves and custom woodwork add a touch of refined elegance. A showstopping curved staircase winds its way to the second floor, adding a touch of architectural drama. This home's unique blend of eclectic design elements creates a chic ambiance with vibrant pops of color and playful accents adding a touch of whimsy to every room. Anyone who needs or wants to work from home here can use one of the three downstairs guest bedrooms as a comfortable and productive home office. The second floor features a luxurious primary suite, a private retreat to unwind and recharge. An additional living space provides a cozy spot to have a fun game night or enjoy a movie. The ensuite bathroom with its high-end fixtures and finishes create a serene and indulgent atmosphere. The property also includes a spacious 2-car garage and a rustic barn which offers extra storage or a workshop space. The outdoor space here is truly exceptional. A magnificent inground pool, with the breathtaking mountain view as its backdrop, is the centerpiece of this outdoor oasis. The enclosed backyard area offers a variety of amenities for relaxation and entertainment, including a soothing hot tub, a pergola and grill area perfect for hosting gatherings, and ample seating and lounging space for you and your guests to enjoy. With over 5 acres of outdoor space at your disposal, the possibilities are endless. Located in picturesque Prattsville, you're minutes from all the best the Catskills have to offer: hiking trails, charming small towns, and local dining. Hunter Mountain and Windham are just a short drive away for skiing and year-round adventure, or Tannersville for shopping and dining. This historic gem offers the perfect blend of privacy, charming beauty, and convenience. The house can come furnished (with a few exclusions) so you can move right in and start to enjoy. Don't miss your chance to own a slice of Catskills serenity—schedule your showing today and let this house welcome you home.
Single-familyProperty Type
1754Year Built
5.17 acresLot Size
$341Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
2 car garageParking
Listing by Kate Quintard• Compass Greater NY, LLC
Listing by Jason Nadeau• Compass Greater NY, LLC
Bought with Jocelyn Justiniano• Compass Greater NY, LLC
Listing by Windstar Realty Group LLC, (607) 442-4000
See all
Provided by Redfin
Sale history for 89 Cartwright Rd
Date
Event
Price
HVCRMLS #20251994
Nov 24, 2025
Sold
$990,000
$363/sq ft
Sep 9, 2025
Pending
—
Jun 5, 2025
Listed
$995,000
$365/sq ft
HVCRMLS #20250243
Jan 28, 2025
Listed
$1,100,000
$403/sq ft
HVCRMLS #138656
Dec 20, 2021
Sold
$729,000
$267/sq ft
Jul 28, 2021
Listed
$625,000
$229/sq ft
HVCRMLS #20212875
Dec 20, 2021
Sold
$729,000
$267/sq ft
Jul 28, 2021
Listed
$625,000
$229/sq ft
+29
Rarely will you find another to compare to this unique Catskill compound. With heritage that goes back to 1754 makes this home perhaps one of the oldest properties in the area kept in the same family for the past 50 years now hits the market for the next generation. This magical estate sits prominently atop the knoll perfectly positioned to survey the jaw dropping mountain views and rich lands that back up to forever wild NY State property. Other prominent features on display are the massive hand-hewn Hemlock ceiling beams, original wood floorboards and original post and beam barn. Additions were put on the 70's and 2000's and is now at the point where it needs cosmetic updates to bring up to today's standards, if done correctly, this home will be a million-dollar showstopper. In ground pool is visually stunning, you can imagine entertaining outdoor parties or hosting micro events du jour. The grounds boast hand laid stonewalls, mature Oak trees, a pond and seasonal brook. Wow!
As the MLS and public records start to fill up, we'll list the details here.